Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Charlie Kaufman is best know as an acclaimed film writer , but he ’s also directed three films , the most recent of which is the Netflix filmI’m Thinking Of Ending Things . The movie star Jessie Buckley and Jesse Plemons , with David Thewlis and Toni Collette appearing in supporting roles . One of his other extremely regarded films isEternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind , starring Kate Winslet and Jim Carrey .
Both films explore the nuances in a seemingly idealistic kinship , and both of them dally with time . The Netflix motion-picture show almost becomes a horror moving-picture show when Jake drive his girlfriend to encounter his parent , whileEternalis more of a surreal sci - fi in which the focal lovers wipe out memories of each other . But when put side by side , which Kaufman film is the best and which one is more heartbreaking ?
ENDING THINGS: It Has More Believable Characters
Perhaps it ’s because of the more modern mise en scene , or the lack of sci - fi elements , or just the fashion they ’re written . Either elbow room , Jake and his girlfriend feel more likereal peoplethan Clementine and Joel do .
Clementine is wild , flash and larger - than - lifetime , unwittingly becoming the codifier for the Manic Pixie Dream Girl archetype . Meanwhile , Joel ’s emotions are too well accessible for a genuine person . Of course , that ’s the point , but viewer may retrieve it easier to identify with the reference of Iain Reid ’s creation , who act more like people in substantial life sentence than movie characters ( minus the horror elements ) .
ETERNAL SUNSHINE: It’s Easier To Comprehend
Though the movie incorporates sci - fi constituent , Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindis much mere in its plot - which is say something , dedicate how tangled it is - thanI’m cerebration Of Ending Things .
The storyisn’t exactly linear , but it ’s still loose to savvy than the latter , which defies constraints of blank and sentence . The characters ofEternalpretty much set everything out on the page , while Jake and Lucy barely ever say what they stand for - in fact , they ’re not even " material " to begin with .
ENDING THINGS: It’s More Nuanced
By no means isEternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindsimple or wanting deepness , but it ’s not quite as nuanced and layered as the Netflix film .
Perhaps becauseI’m Thinking Of Ending Thingsis found on a novel , Kaufman had more material to squeeze into the protracted film . His Netflix film explores many subject that broaden far beyond this couple ’s relationship in manner thatEternalcouldn’t .
ETERNAL SUNSHINE: It Has A Faster Pace
While by no mean value boring , I’m mean Of Ending Thingsdoes seem to drag on a flake , especially on the first spotter . The film takes place in the course of study of a single evening , imply witness have to sit down through many confusing and sometimes tedious conversation between its two independent character reference .
Meanwhile , the Winslet and Carrey picture show tells the story ofa series of events . Things are perpetually changing , and the passage of time is mark by Clementine ’s hairsbreadth . Though scramble in a non - linear style , there ’s a clear progression of events and fourth dimension inEternalas compared to a surreal dateless night .
ENDING THINGS: It’s More Unique
While storage loss has been explored in numerous dad culture texts , whateverI’m Thinking Of Ending Thingstampers with is pretty alone . Not many films or level like it have ever been created before , even if they do have similar elements and composition . The enjoyment of magical Platonism in special does marvel for the tarradiddle and really helps to get the message across .
That being said , Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindis also unique in its own direction , but perhaps not as innovative as Kaufman ’s previous . While it ’s heavy to pin down whatI’m Thinking Of Ending Thingsreally is , Eternalcan be classified as a surrealist deconstruction of a romanticistic comedy .
ETERNAL SUNSHINE: It’s Considerably Less Gloomy
This is n’t to say that this motion picture does n’t have its fair part of heartbreak and tragedy , but the overall tone of the film is nowhere near as dour and stark asI’m think Of Ending Thingsis .
The Netflix motion-picture show takes place almost entirely at dark , already itself a glooming sentence of day . Itscolor palette is blue , as are the radical of ageing , demise , suicide , and meter . Meanwhile , Clementine and Joel live in a bright , colorful world of many options , and their romance total a lot of light to the movie .
ENDING THINGS: It Leaves An Impact
possibly it ’s because of the film ’s curiousness or it ’s because of a off-the-wall and pretty bare conclusion , butI’m think Of Ending Thingslingers with viewers more than Kaufman ’s early picture show .
The conclusion is open - complete , but it also does n’t give too much to be explored . Jessie Buckley’scharacter does n’t even existin reality , nor does the variation of Jake looker see , so these characters do n’t have a future . But the concluding thirty minutes are so off-the-wall and unearthly that it stays with the audience long after watching it .
ETERNAL SUNSHINE: It Has Higher Emotional Stakes
For all intents and purposes , Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindis a love affair , whereI’m Thinking Of Ending Thingspresents a yoke that viewers know will not subsist the moving picture .
The interview should be root for Clementine and Joel , and they do , but they ’re not supposed to require Jake to experience out his phantasy with Lucy / Lucia / Louisa / etc . Clementine and Joel ’s undoing is heartrending , and thus the moving picture is worth find out for its emotional take .
ENDING THINGS: It’s Fun To Watch
Besides the farseeing , drawn - out sequences of driving through a snowstorm , this film is exciting and fun to watch . One never knows what ’s around the come curved shape in the road , and they ’re incessantly at the edge of their seats waiting to see what ’s next .
All of the histrion give incredible public presentation , but the most memorable might just be from Jake ’s parents , played by Toni Collette and David Thewlis . In accession , the film is rife with references to other pop culture texts , citing musicals , poems , film critics , and more . The end offers a wild equipment into melodic house district , as well as magical realism in the form of a sketch pig .
ETERNAL SUNSHINE: It’s Surprisingly Hopeful
Despite everything that happens over the course of its runtime , Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindsomehow proves to be more hopeful for its fiber . Also , the message it ’s sending is much more optimistic .
I ’m believe Of Ending Thingspresumably ends with the janitor ’s suicide or death , while the fancy version of himself wins something like a Nobel Prize while Jessie Buckley ’s character proudly applaud . ButEternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mindgives viewers trust for the real version ofClementine and Joel , not only as a couple but as mortal too .
NEXT : Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind : Michel Gondry ’s 10 Best Films ( agree To IMDb )
