Most the great unwashed who ’ve wear Superman ’s suit of clothes have had their ploughshare of highs and lows , and Henry Cavill is no unlike . While the actor has of late win hearts in hisWitcherandEnola Holmesroles , as well as in his amazingly famous figurer - construction video that quickly became a meme , his success is n’t without its controversial moments .

In some ways , Cavill fully stepped into the part of the DCEU’sSupermanand did the cape justice . But in others , he either fall flat or even sank well below expectations at time , leaving fans longing for a replacement .

Most Heroic: He Brought Gravitas To The Suit

Cavill sometimes catches fire for being " too serious , " but Superman is one of the most serious superheroes in risible history . He ’s not known for his wisecracking or grinning , so hoi polloi require to turn back severalise the alien to smile more often . That ’s like sayingHugh Jackman was n’t a good Wolverinebecause he was too hoarse . Lois & Clarkmight’ve been cunning and entertaining , but it for certain was n’t representative of the heart ofSuperman .

Sure , Man of Steelgot a little too dour and gloomy at times , but Superman takes his job quite seriously . Cavill really reflected   the hero ’s justice - seeking soul with attending and science . It’slikely that this portraiture will be even more impressive in the Snyder Cut .

Worst: He Made Jabs At #MeToo

Superman would never say that he was afraid to particular date because he did n’t need to get blame or accuse of something he did n’t do , and these insensitive remark reflected ill on Cavill . He apologized for his choice of intelligence almost immediately .

Most Heroic: He Struggled With His Identity

Anyone who hump comics knows that most heroes shinny with their personal identity at some point , especially regarding how their superhero persona fit into their alter ego ’s life , or vice versa . In Superman ’s case , the two identities intermingle so much that it ’s truss to create tension and Cavill demonstrate this beautifully . These minute were some of the best ofCavill ’s time in the cape .

Unfortunately , Cavill was n’t given virtually enough time to really search this issue in the DCEU . The chance to examine what his identity intend to him beyond his childhood could really give him the opportunity to grow as the Man of Steel .

Worst: He Didn’t Lead

At some level , Superman want to shine as a beacon of promise while at the same time rallying the troop .   Fans have yet to really see him demonstrate the vigor needed tohelm the Justice League , which is really one of the greatest flaws about Cavill ’s Superman .

Much like Marvel ’s Captain America , Superman represents Doing The Right affair , and he need to be inspirational to the masses while doing it . That does n’t mean he has to be as wizardly as George Reeves , but he needs to at least be able to deliver a semi - uplifting speech complete with a power mannerism .

Most Heroic: He Leveled With Lois

Lois is ordinarily portrayed as someone who , despite regularly being in the presence of both Clark Kent and Superman , is completely incognizant that they are one and the same . She ’s even been a petty ditzy in some of the preceding Superman flick . That ’s whyAmy Adams ’s Lois Lane was so refreshful , and why Cavill ’s character is one of the best version in terms of their relationship … at least , at first .

Lois and Clark are partners who assist one another and have their own disjoined bow . Lois ’s agency inMan of Steelis very welcome after so many damozel in distress floor .

Worst: He Didn’t Value Life

What kind of Superman defeat multitude ? It ’s all right to go dreary , even broody , but whenSuperman does n’t even seem conflictedabout take a life , it was n’t just anti - Supes ; it was anti - everything he stand for .

Sure , the Man of Steel has occupy life in the yesteryear , but it ’s always been an exception to the rule   — his own normal . It ’s one thing when it ’s perfectly necessary and unavoidable , but when it for sure face like he can get by with apprehend a villain — not to mention when it ’s not even explained why he does n’t choose his normal route of economize the day — and he offs someone anyway , it ’s dead antiheroic .

Most Heroic: He Looked The Most Like Superman

Cavill is arguably the close any actor has occur to looking like Clark Kent himself . From the Kuki to the human body , he nails the appearance of Superman .

Some might argue that it ’s a superficial point . The appearance   of a sub like   Storm   orAquaman is much more flexiblesince their powers and identities are n’t as tied in with their looks . But while a torpedo surely is n’t made by spirit alone , certain hoagie — like Superman and Captain America — have a hallmark   aesthetic that is very much a part of who they are .

Worst: He Destroyed So Much Property

Superman ’s tremendous craters left in his wake got previous quickly after marketing crusade ran them to death . It pay back to the distributor point where the grinder ’s debris became his vocation posting more than anything else , and while everyone like a good superhero dumbfound ,   all of that collateral price just made Supes look a turn sloppy .

On one hand , it sends the important substance that lives are much more valuable than attribute . On the other , when Alfred call Batman out on the mess hall he raffishly pass on behind during his high - speed chase , he was veracious . Both heroes could reign in the destruction a bit .

Most Heroic: He Was Flawed

Too many people are under the depression that because Superman is nearly invulnerable , he is also perfect . As any mirthful reader know , this is far from the case , and one of Cavill ’s triumph was aptly establish that no matter how many powers Clark has , he ’s still blemished , which is what make him so akin to the human being that he protects .

The shot where he ’s learning to fly is a fantastic monstrance of these imperfectness . Sometimes Superman did n’t seem upset enough about   his flaws , like when he was destroying everything around him , but he did have more iron matters to attend to at the time .

Worst: He Wasn’t Truly The Man Of Steel

At no flaw of Cavill himself , the DCEU Superman character cease up being write as a flimsy cardboard cutout of the Superman we all know and enjoy . Too many rewrite are to blame here , with Superman alternating from a darker , more violent version of himself to a generic quality that some have even winced at and dubbed a " Mary Sue . "

As such , Cavill unfortunately just was n’t as interesting as the actual Superman , which is a disgrace since the actor has long since demonstrated what he can bring to a project with some good writing behind it . Many fans have high hope that he ’ll have a better shot with succeeding projects .

NEXT : Henry Cavill : 5 Most Iconic & 5 Most Forgettable persona

James Gunn’s Superman and Krypto comic

How Goku can beat Superman, explained.

Lex Luthot comic and live action

Henry Cavill Superman Feature

Henry Cavill as Clark Kent Superman in Batman V Superman

Henry Cavill as Clark Kent in Superman

Louis and Superman look at each other after kissing

henry cavill man of steel superman clark kent batman v superman

Amy Adams as Lois Lane in Man of Steel

Superman kills Zod in Man of Steel

Superman Henry Cavill Recolor

Batman V Superman Trailer Battle Destruction

Opening of Justice League

Henry Cavill’s Superman and the DCEU Opening Sequence

Movies

Superman