The Shining
Ewan McGregor took over the role ofThe Shining ’s Dan Torrance in the 2019 sequelDoctor Sleep , but who else was considered for the iconic part?The Haunting of Hill Househelmer / horror hitmaker Mike Flanagan had a raremiss at the box position with last year’sDoctor Sleep , the long - expect sequel to Stephen King ’s classic novel , The Shining . The source novel of the same name also debuted to mixed reviews , but the film was uniquely critically divisive as it observe up Kubrick ’s 1980 film version ofThe Shining .
Kubrick ’s pic made unnumberable changes to King ’s original novel during its infamously torment production , with the quicksilver conductor turning a tragic psychological horror about addiction and generational trauma into wintry cold , blackly mirthful mystery rife with symbolisation and surrealism . King magnificently initially hated the version , and the author had a far bad role inDoctor Sleep ’s journey to the screen , even giving his blessing to the casting ofMoulin Rougestar Ewan McGregor as the grown - up Danny Torrance . Doctor Sleepsuccessfully accost a hatful ofwhat King detest about Kubrick’sThe Shiningbut the cinema however fall flat , leading McGregor ’s cast to necessarily be called into question .
Related : Doctor Sleep Director ’s Cut Balances The Stephen King Book Better
But who else was take for the role , and could they have savedDoctor Sleepfrom middling vital response ? It ’s voiceless to tell whether Flanagan ’s adaptation could ever have emerge from the phantasma of Kubrick ’s infamous horror motion-picture show , but actors Dan Stevens , Chris Evans , Matt Smith , and Jeremy Renner were all come on for the part of Danny before McGregor assume on the persona . It ’s well-heeled to see where the film maker were coming from with each of these actors , each of whom has a unique appeal ( and unique drawback ) when it comes to the role of Danny inDoctor Sleep .
Matt Smith is mostly make love for less villainous theatrical role like thetitle character ofDoctor Who , but the actor does have a strong history in horror with a part inPride and Prejudice and Zombiesand the lead part of Patrick Bateman in theAmerican Psychostage musical to his name . He ’s also not averse to play existent - life sentence monsters likeCharlie Says ' furore leader ( and CIA PI ) Charles Manson . at last , it ’s hard to see Smith as an all - American everyman like Dan , a problem partake in by his fellow countryman Dan Stevens . Stevens ' success in the the likes of ofLegionprove he can play touch , virtuously ambiguous antihero , but he ’s very British and Danny is not . While his accent passed selective service in early genre fare , it would face up a set more examination when he ’s not playingThe Guest ’s debatably human superintendent - soldier .
Jeremy Renner had potential in the part , but he ’s a bit dour for someone playing Jack Nicholson ’s offspring . While Hawkeye has gravitas , McGregor ’s turn inTrainspottingproves he can mix nervy charm with a demilitarise mean run where Renner is all bad guy cable frown and no toothy smiling . The final — and cheeseparing — contender , Chris Evans would have been the best choice other than McGregor . Knives Outproved that Evans can play villain as well as paladin , and the actor has explored dark territorial dominion inSnowpiercer . But ever since he bulked up for the role of Captain America , Evans does n’t have the nervy intensity that McGregor and Nicholson both share .
AlthoughDoctor Sleep ’s status as aShiningsequelarguably doomed the movie , the picture needed to partake in some tonal similarity with its herald . As such , a stringy , vaguely jeopardise aureole that McGregor and Nicholson possess made the Scottish doer a natural choice for the unmanageable function in Flanagan’sDoctor Sleep .
More : The Shining : What " The Shine " Really Is Explained ( Origins & Powers )
