Related
The trailer for Denis Villeneuve ’s adaptation ofDuneshows quite a few differences from the1984 version , and the 2020Duneadaptationlooks to be a more close take on Frank Herbert ’s sci - fi novel . rooter have already taken to Youtube with shot - by - blastoff comparison videos and analysis of likely changes . What are these alteration , and how will they impact the film ?
Multiple hoi polloi havetried to adapt the 1965 novelDune — and failedto do so in a square manner . Alejandro Jodorowsky tried to make aDunemovie in the mid - seventies , but it never got off the ground . In 2000 , Sci Fi Channel aired the miniseriesFrank Herbert ’s Dune . However , most ill-famed is David Lynch’sDune(1984 ) – a film that even Lynch admit was a failure . If Villeneuve wants to avoid Lynch ’s fate , he ’ll want to make quite a few change in his variation ofDune – and based on the trailer , it looks like he has .
Related : Dune 2020 : Why The Movie Is In Two Parts ( Where Will Part 1 terminal ? )
While aesthetic changes are to be expected between a 1984 movie and a 2020 one , there are other differences that might indicate something larger . Certain characters might have small purpose , and , as cite earlier , it seems that Villeneuve is sticking to the source material more closely than Lynch did .
Dune 2020 Features Caladan
There are several shots in theDune2020 trailer that feature stretch of beach and establishing shots of water . These are most - potential depictions of the sea planet Caladan , where theDunenovel begins . In the novel , the House Atreides ( the primary character ’s family ) are relocated from Caladan to the desert planet Arrakis , a.k.a . Dune . Lynch ’s 1984 version largely skitter over Caladan , alternatively take property mostly on Dune .
Lady Jessica’s Role
Lady Jessica ( Rebecca Ferguson ) is a major type in theDunenovel and in the 1984 moving picture . She is the female parent of the chief role , Paul ( Timothee Chalamet ) and a part of an fabulously influential chemical group of women called the Bene Gesserit . The Bene Gesserit are an ancient order with the ultimate destination of creating the Kwisatz Haderach , a male Bene Gesserit with everlasting omniscience . Since Paul is the Kwisatz Haderach , Jessica ’s role inDuneis crucial .
In theDune2020 trailer , however , she scarce appear . Jessica is only in a smattering of shots and does n’t have any lines – she ’s even absent from scene likethe Gom Jabbar testwhere the Reverend Mother of the Bene Gesserit appear . found on her limited appearance , it ’s potential that her role is slightly belittle from the 1984 film to this version ofDune . Of of course , there ’s also the possibility that her character is just as large , but that her picture simply did n’t make it into the trailer .
The Sandworms Have a Different Appearance
Sandworms – jumbo underground creatures that terrorise the human inhabitants of planet Arrakis and produce thevaluable drug mishmash , cognise as " spiciness " – look totally unlike in this version ofDune . The iconic monsters fromDunehave a distinct show in the 2020 trailer than in the 1984 movie . procession in hard-nosed effects and CGI , as well as change in hearing sense of taste , partly accounts for the deviation in appearance ; however , this change seems to be more of a conceptual reinvention than a purely aesthetic one .
Related : Dune 2020 Is A Major Box Office peril : Can It Avoid Being A Failure ?
In the 1984 film ( and in the miniseries ) , the sandworms have a head determine like leaves , and their mouths are full of curt , penetrative tooth . The coming into court of these teeth emphasizes the Fremen practice of collecting Sandworm teeth to apply as knives – this is a rather telling effort , since finding a bushed sandworm is exceedingly rare . In this rendering ofDune , however , the sandworms look more like a vacuum and have massive teeth . They ’re just as frightening ( arguably more so ! ) , but they seem far too gravid to be practical as knife and therefore the design do n’t suggest to Fremen culture like the 1984 version did .
Ornithopters Have Wings
InDune , ornithopters are outer space ship used for modest chemical group of people traveling short distances . Extremely common fomite , they are a fundamental feature oftheDuneuniverse ’s worldbuilding . In both the 2000 miniseries and the 1984 film , Dunecharacters ride and drive orthopter frequently . The vehicle seem in the 2020 version ofDune , but it looks slightly different . While the early adaptations ofDuneshow orthopter with stationary wings , Villeneuve ’s variation include move dragonfly - alike wings – a choice that more accurately represents the source cloth ( with an insectoid twist ) . While this is a comparatively underage item , it may be an meter reading that the picture as a whole will be truthful to the book than Lynch ’s film was . Since Lynch’sDunewas intemperately criticized for straying too far from the leger , this would be a good move for Villeneuve .
Personal Shields and Knife Combat
InDune , almost everyone wears a protective shield nearly all the time . These shell are energy fields that envelop whoever wears them and offer protective cover from object run above a certain fastness – sluggish front are permitted to glide by through the field , allowing the person wearing the buckler to breathe . The only weapon that can penetrate the carapace without an burst is a hand-held dagger that is moving at a slow enough speeding for the shield to permit it . Due to this queer vulnerability , tongue fighting is a plebeian fighting method inDune .
Related : Dune 2020 : Paul Atreides Powers & Origin Explained
The buckler inDune1984 are not completely exact to the book . While the book of account describe the shields as form - meet , the 1984 film depicts shields as with child square that protrude from the character ’s skin and blur their face and body . As with the ornithopters , the portrayal of shields is much more accurate inDune2020 , as the carapace only appears as a blue light that flash upon impact . This not only looks intimately but also allow the audience to distinctly see the characters . The 1984 shields should n’t be knock too harshly , however ; Lynch likely did the best he could with the technology available at the metre .
Some Elements are Missing
Lynch made some addition to theDuneuniverse with his film . First is a “ weirding module ” – a weapon that turn sounds into attacks . sure sound quick more potent fire , with Paul ’s Fremen name , Muad’Dib , being a black one . These weirding modules do not exist in the book , and Lynch added them in to exchange the Bene Gesserit Weirding Way , which he did not think would work well on silver screen . TheDune2020 trailer makes no mention of these weirding modules , so it ’s likely that they wo n’t be included in this version . Another somewhat strange increase that Lynch made is a pug-dog . InDune1984 , the Atreides crime syndicate has a pet dog , and he has a decent amount of screen prison term . It ’s unclear why Lynch choose to impart a dog to the plaster cast , and most fans accord that it was an unnecessary inclusion . Meanwhile , the trailer for Villeneuve ’s rendering shows no signs of pug .
There ’s a trend to the difference between the 2020 and 1984 variation ofDune : where Lynch seemed to tramp off from the novel , Villeneuve stays patriotic to it . However , a two - hour - long movie has a good deal more time to tramp away from the source material than a three - minute - farseeing trailer does , and it ’s possible thatDune2020 makes some changes to the original novel that are not featured in the trailer . Hopefully , theDunetrailer accurately reflects the storyand tone for the movie as a whole , and die - hardDunefans will see a film adjustment that is truthful to the book .
More : Dune 2020 : What Does " Fear Is The Mind Killer " bastardly ?
