Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi
The act 3 plot of land twist inThe Empire Strikes Backchanged the course of action of theStar Warssaga , and while its privateness was protected with a simulated divine revelation , the trilogy could have been much obscure if it was the real twist . Darth Vader ’s infamous dialogue , which reveals that he is Luke ’s begetter , Anakin Skywalker , is iconic enough to be known by those unfamiliar with theStar Warsfranchise , but it was n’t simply a twist for the rice beer of being unexpected . Vader ’s Apocalypse completelyrecontextualizesA New Hopeand inform some of the most dramatic and touching instant in its sequel , Return of the Jedi . What is n’t almost as iconic , however , is the “ twist ” told to Mark Hamill duringEmpire’sfilming , which would have takenStar Warsin a drastically dissimilar counselling .
Darth Vader ’s “ I am your sire ” line is a meaningful game spin that is n’t fully pass judgment until its continuation , Return of the Jedi . Luke take from his mentor that Obi - Wan feels creditworthy for Anakin ’s fall to the dark side but also see Darth Vader as a different person than his former apprentice ( a sentiment reinforced incanon and LegendsStar Warsmaterial outside of the films ) . With this cognition , Luke resolves to redeem his father rather than kill him , lead in some of the enfranchisement ’s greatest moment . Luke uses his transmitted attachment to his Father-God to bring out what full remains in Vader , makingReturn of the Jedia remarkably satisfying decision to both the original trilogy and the story of Anakin Skywalker .
interrelate : What If Luke Became A Jedi & Killed Vader Before Empire ’s Father Twist ?
George Lucas andEmpire Strikes Backdirector Irvin Kirshner preserved the secrecy of the film ’s major braid from even the cast , with the purport false twist being that Darth Vader would say “ Obi - Wan killed your father ” or else of “ I am your male parent . ” While this would n’t have resulted in the same fascinating characterization thatLuke , Vader , and Obi - Wanall receive inReturn of the Jedi , it would have still been an unexpected twist that changes the row of the trilogy and , afterwards , theStar Warssaga . Considering that Obi - Wan is show to be a heroic Jedi and kindly mentor to Luke , this would have accept the films in an unexpectedly dark-skinned direction , as Anakin was known up to this stage as a good man who fell to Kenobi ’s former pupil . Here ’s howEmpire’sfalse plot turn might have affected theStar Warssaga if it was the real one .
Obi-Wan Could’ve Become Luke’s Enemy In Return Of The Jedi
While it ’s highly unlikely that Obi - Wan would be retroactively made a villain , the Book of Revelation that he ’d kill Anakin would have disturbing implication inReturn of the Jedithat would belike put him at odds with Luke Skywalker . For Obi - Wan to have killed Anakin , one of the two would have needed toturn to the dark side . In Anakin ’s instance , he might have fallen along with Vader ( a separate reference in this scenario ) , and his conflict with Obi - Wan would end with his last . If Obi - Wan fell , he might have contend against Anakin , who he kill before realizing how far he ’s fall , causing him to turn down the black side . In either case , his dynamic with Luke would become far more unfriendly once Luke learns the truth .
Anakin vs Obi-Wan Would’ve Ended Different In Revenge Of The Sith
No matter who falls to the dark side , the duel between Obi - Wan and Anakin would have a far more macabre ending in this alternate saga ’s version ofStar Wars : Episode III – retaliation of the Sith . If Anakin falls to the dingy side , Obi - Wan might have made the difficult determination to decisively stamp out him during the affaire d’honneur for the goodness of the galaxy , despite their friendly relationship . If Obi - Wan had turned to the morose side , he ’d have kill his acquaintance , though perhaps not like a shot or in cold blood , as he ’d need to return to the Jedi ways after realizing how close he ’s come to the point of no getting even .
Darth Vader Being A Separate Character Would’ve Changed The Sith
Darth Vader and Anakin Skywalker being separate characters could also importantly change the Sith . Whether Obi - Wan or Anakin falls to the saturnine side , they ’d probably have puzzle out alongside the fallen Darth Vader , meaning that the famous Sith Rule of Two would no longer exist , as Emperor Palpatine is already revealed to be a Sith inTheEmpire Strikes Back . Palpatinemight have organise the downfall of both Vader and Anakin ( or Obi - Wan ) , or simply did n’t object to more than one Jedi cover the colored side . This would add more narrative weight to Obi - Wan and Yoda ’s monition to Luke not to undervalue the Emperor .
Related : What If Han Solo Had die In The Original Star Wars Trilogy
Star Wars Is More Morally Gray Because Of Obi-Wan
TheStar Warsfranchise , on the surface , seems to leave little room for refinement when the heroes and villains appear so intelligibly stigmatise and rank . Despite this , Return of the Jediproves how well - suited the enfranchisement is to moral gray areas more than any other live - actionStar Warsfilm . In this alternative saga , however , this could still be the case , albeit in a far darker physique . Obi - Wan killing Anakin would recontextualize Yoda ’s word that the dark side will forever “ dominate your circumstances , ” no matter who became corrupted . ForObi - Wan , his time on Tatooinewould be more akin to exile as a mode to bring back to the ways of the Jedi . In Anakin ’s instance , it ’d be a sign that the old Jedi plow their enemies almost as ruthlessly as the Sith .
What Would Anakin & Darth Vader’s Relationship Be Like?
Darth Vader would be far less charitable in this reading of theStar Warssaga . Without his background knowledge as Anakin , Luke might not be as motivated to redeem him . With Emperor Palpatine pose as the saga ’s main scoundrel , however , as well as Vader ’s connectedness with Anakin and Obi - Wan , he might form a unaffixed connective with Luke , who perhaps sees his fall to the grim side as being comparable to that of Anakin or Obi - Wan . Vader would likely die out by the end ofReturn of the Jedianyway , but Luke ( and thus the viewers ) might see him as a far more complex character .
Darth Vader’s Redemption Could Be Very Different
Darth Vader ’s repurchase inReturn of the Jediwould not be prompt by Luke ’s desire to keep open his don , but likely by the touch of Obi - Wan and Anakin reveal their experiences with the dark side to Luke . Luke might insist that Vader must be killed for all the damage he ’s done to his family and the beetleweed writ large , but Obi - Wan and Anakin would urge him to see the nuance in his descent , accept that the honest-to-god Jedi ways were flawed . TheStar Warssaga would be overall darker if it used the false twist inThe Empire Strikes Back , but it ’d still finish on a hopeful note for Luke and the future tense of the Jedi .
Next : How caption Already Gave Star Wars Its Own What If … ? serial
