Related
The third instalment in the Wizarding World enfranchisement , Fantastic Beasts : The Secrets of DumbledoreretconsHarry Potterin a few significant ways , while largely still being an improvement on its prompt forerunner . Debuting back in 2016,Fantastic wildcat and Where to Find Themwas for the most part a whimsical standalone adventure , very much revolve about around magizoologist Newt Scamander ( Eddie Redmayne ) . However , the movie gave hints towards a big Wizarding World story , unveilingGellert Grindelwald ( Johnny Depp)at the very end , which led to some important issues in the sequel .
Fantastic Beasts : The Crimes of Grindelwaldcrossed over much more now with theHarry Potterseries , bringing in Albus Dumbledore ( Jude Law ) while also making Grindelwald a chief eccentric . With that , it also led to some bigHarry Potterretcons ; there was , of grade , the reveal that Credence Barebone ( Ezra Miller ) is really Aurelius Dumbledore , but also a modification in Professor McGonagall ’s age too , having her teach at Hogwarts long before had been previously established . Thanks toPottermore , interviews , and social media , add-on to and retcons ofHarry Pottercanon had already become somewhat well-worn even prior to these motion picture , butFantastic Beastsmade them magnanimous and seen en masse .
Related : fantastical Beasts 3 Ending Explained & Future Setup ( In Detail )
AfterThe Crimes of Grindelwaldunderperformed at the box officeand with critic , alongside ongoing behind - the - scenes contention , Fantastic brute : The Secrets of Dumbledoreis very much a class correction . The movie ameliorate upon what came before in several ways , with a more exciting story , warm characterisation , and a greater sense of capture the admiration and magic trick of the Wizarding World . At the same prison term , while far from movie - ruining , it does retcon elements of canon and massively reframe or re - contextualise others . Here are all the waysFantastic savage 3retconsHarry Potter .
Fantastic Beasts 3 Retcons Ariana Dumbledore’s Death
Ariana Dumbledore ’s death is one of the most tragical backstory elements from theHarry Potterbooks and movies , the biggest planetary house of Albus Dumbledore ’s darker past that most people are completely incognizant of . away from confirm that Ariana was an Obscurial , wild Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledoremakes some other changes to her story . Harry Potterhad previously establish that Ariana ’s demise was a result of a three - elbow room duel between Aberforth , Albus , and Gellert Grindelwald at the Dumbledore homein Godric ’s Hollow . InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , it ’s said that Aberforth confronted his brother over his and Grindelwald ’s plans , suppose he could n’t take over the earthly concern with their baby in toe ; a course broke out that cursorily escalated , with Grindelwald using the Cruciatus Curse on Aberforth and a bigger combat breaking out . Ariana seek to assist , and was hit and killed by a isolated spell .
Dumbledore retells these events to Newt Scamander inFantastic animal 3 , keeping some of the detail the same - a row between the two blood brother , Ariana unwittingly hitch in the crossfire , not knowing who stamp out her - but retconsHarry Potterin one fundamental way : Grindelwald ’s affaire . Rather than mentioning theuse of an Unforgivable Curse , Dumbledore say that he just stood there and express joy when the two brothers drew their wands on one another . It ’s possible , of course , that later in the duel he did get involved , but it ’s a strange omission that colors Ariana ’s death otherwise ; while it ’s long been very possible anyway that Albus was the one who cast the fatal piece , if there were only two combatants then it makes it more likely , while it would also explain why Aberforth was so furious at his crony , build it even more personal between them .
Fantastic Beasts 3 Changes Aberforth’s “Secrets” Line From Harry Potter
WithFantastic Beasts 3titledThe Secrets of Dumbledore , the laying claim was that it was name to Albus . After all , there was plenty of apparatus to explore his part and backstory further , and as one of thebiggest characters inHarry Potter , yet one around whom there stay on some closed book , it ’d only be rude for more secrets to be uncovered . In a sense the motion-picture show is about those secret , especially as it uncovers more of Dumbledore and Grindelwald ’s kinship , but the braggy closed book of all belong to Aberforth , and it ’s in that whereFantastic Beasts 3retconsHarry Potter , or at least reframes it .
link up : Fantastic creature 3 : Dumbledore ’s design To Defeat Grindelwald Explained ( Properly )
InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , Aberforth differentiate Harry:“Secrets and Lie , that ’s how we grew up , and Albus , he was a natural . “In the same passage , he also questions why Harry - or anyone - would ever trust Albus , and it ’s very clear that he still has a deep rancor and mistrust of his brother , the implication of which is that Albus was the most secretive and misleading of them all . However , that ’s not entirely the suit , with it confirmed thatCredence , or Aurelius , is Aberforth ’s son , a secret he on the face of it harbored for several years that is as big as any Albus himself carried . The circumstances around that are complicated , sure , butFantastic wildcat 3changes the Harry Potter line , further emphasising the"we"aspect in showing that Aberforth too was intelligibly something of a natural at it , and making it feel more than a minuscule hypocritical to boot .
Fantastic Beasts 3’s Albus & Aberforth Have A Closer Relationship Than Harry Potter’s
Alongside changing the nature of Aberforth ’s line about Albus , Fantastic Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledorealso reframes the brother ' relationship . InHarry Potter , where Aberforth is hardly bring up anyway , there ’s a genuine signified of bitterness from him towards his brother . It made sense , given what had happened with Ariana , and implied that Aberforth had never really forgiven Albus for what take place to their sister . Fantastic Beasts 3makes Albus and Aberforthseem much close : they ’re still not exactly the in effect of supporter , but there ’s a clearer sense of kinship , with Albus ' meal at the Hog ’s Head implied to be a even occurrence .
Albus did visit the Hog ’s Head on occasion because the quieter bar had its uses - such as interviewing Sybil Trelawney there - but there was no material sense of the relationship they have here . It ’s possible it existed off - page , of class , or that the resentment grew over the years , as Albus became Headmaster of Hogwarts , was the man many want for Minister of Magic , took the side of Supreme Mugwump , and in the main was the Wizarding World ’s great hero , when Aberforth lie with the the true about him , butFantastic animal 4and5(if they happen)could show the pair growing further apart too .
Albus Dumbledore Is Pure Of Heart? That Doesn’t Fit Harry Potter
Speaking of Albus Dumbledore becoming Supreme Mugwump , it ’s something that almost come about inFantastic Beasts 3as well . After Grindelwald has been exposed , the literal Qilin bows before him , having looked into his mortal and deciding that he was the gross of heart among them . There ’s no doubting Dumbledore is among the greatest wizards to have ever lived and , despite his past mistakes with Grindelwald , a good man . But complete of substance ? That seems a step beyond the Dumbledore ofHarry Potter , who was passing flawed - and that ’s not a unfit thing , as it ’s what helped make his lineament compelling . He kept many secrets , he used people , and was willing to do just about anything necessary , even with the passing of life , to secure thesafety of the Wizarding World from Lord Voldemort ; a noble causal agent , sure , but not one that was defined by his purity . His idea of what"the greater good"was budge massively , but there ’s a sense in which those words were always what drove him in a mode , butFantastic Beasts 3 ’s end retcons that to make him a more pure good and right hero .
come to : Grindelwald ’s Fantastic Beasts & Harry Potter Backstory : Origin , Power & Death
Fantastic Beasts 3 Retcons Dumbledore & Grindelwald’s Duel
One of the first things unwrap about Albus Dumbledore ’s backstory inHarry Potteris that he duelled - and defeated - the dark wizard Grindelwald in 1945 , as look on the back of his coffee toad circuit card . No other context was give then , but it was a tantalizing hint of his unbelievable business leader that would only be designate in flashes across theHarry Potterbooks and movies , such asbattling Lord Voldemort inHarry Potterand the Order of the Phoenix , or facing the Inferi inHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince . With laterHarry Potterbooks shedding more light on Grindelwald , and later theFantastic Beastsfranchise enclose him as a principal fictional character , then the setup is very much to show that 1945 duel , should the enfranchisement get to that point ( which will look on box place ) . However , there was never a acknowledgment of another clangour between them ; indeed , it ’s observe upon that Dumbledore ’s face - off with Grindelwald came after year of the dark wizard ’s warfare being wag , when he could no longer ignore telephone call to face him .
Fantastic Beasts 3retcons Dumbledore and Grindelwald ’s duelby let out they did have an earlier conflict , as the couple do fight in a magical mirror proportion of sorts after their blood pact is broken . After that , Dumbledore call to continue hunting Grindelwald and to vote out him . With that knowledge , then , it pee it stranger that it ask so long to happen , as the timeline suggests it will be more than a decade before Dumbledore duel Grindelwald and beat up him . The suggestion of their 1945 duel was very much that it was a " finally ! " type moment for Dumbledore pace out to face up his friend - turn - foe , but it now reads rather differently , and meansFantastic Beasts 4and5will need to explain the delay .
Fantastic Beasts 3 Retcons The Killing Curse (Twice)
A two - for - one special inFantastic Beasts 3’sHarry Potterretcons , The Secrets of Dumbledoremakes a yoke of change tohow the Killing Curse is used . Harry Potter himself is , of path , the only person know to have ever live the swearing , and beyond thatHarry Pottercanon established a couple of other rules : that Avada Kedavra could n’t be blocked by any distinctive protective spell , and that it killed its intended prey instantly . The exceptions come solely with Harry himself , thanks to the erotic love from his female parent , and then his connectedness to Lord Voldemort and the shared link between their sceptre , butFantastic Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledorehas a couple of other change . In the film ’s opening turn , the female parent Qilin is murder by two Killing Curses , and yet after a lengthy chase succession affect Newt , the baby Qilin , and Grindelwald ’s followers , he regress with the mother still die , but not yet dead . It ’s possible , of course , that thisHarry Potterretconis explained by the Qilin ’s own great wizard power , since it ’s such a rarified brute , but it ’s also done in club to service the secret plan and allow for the death to be drawn out and form the surprisal of the twin Qilin .
tight - forward to the movie ’s net act , and Grindelwald aim a Killing Curse at Credence , with Albus and Aberforth Dumbledore both firing protective spells to block it . It ’s ill-defined what spell they use - producing a gilded magic that suggests something far great than any previously look cuticle magical spell - but the result is saving Credence ’s life . Again , it ’s possible there are explanations for this - it could be a interchangeable scenario toLily Potter saving Harry , where love is the reason it does n’t work out ; it could also be link to Dumbledore and Grindelwald ’s rip pact , which breaks in this moment too - but however it whirl it , it ’s another way ofFantastic Beasts : The Secrets of DumbledoreretconningHarry Potterlore .
Next : Every Harry Potter Character Alive During Fantastic wildcat ' Timeline
Custom Image by SR Editor
Custom Image by SR Editor
