Frozen
Frozen 2creates a plot hole for Queen Iduna ( Evan Rachel Wood ) when her backstory as a fellow member of the Northuldra indigenous radical is introduced in the sequel . When Elsa ( Idina Menzel ) circumstantially spite Anna ( Kristen Bell ) with her internal-combustion engine deception during the opening scene ofFrozen , the action of King Agnarr ( Alfred Molina ) and Queen Iduna that follow as they refer the rock troll suggests that Iduna has slight noesis of conjuring trick in theFrozenuniverse despite growing up in the Enchanted Forest where the Northuldra coexisted with the elemental heart .
Along with King Agnarr , Queen Iduna was introduced very briefly at the beginning ofFrozenas Anna and Elsa ’s female parent . Since her character reference had circumscribed scenes and minimum dialogue , Idunatook on the role of a one - dimensional parental physical body rather than a fully developed persona before hermysterious death in a wreck out at seawithin the opening scenes ofFrozen . InFrozen 2 , however , Queen Iduna ’s role was thrive through the use of goods and services of flashbacks , which supply more insight into Iduna ’s puerility as a Northuldran , revealed how she saved Agnarr during the battle between the Arendellians and the Northuldra people , and how the elemental feel give Elsa with the reincarnate fifth feeling because of Iduna ’s bravery . While Iduna was in the beginning sound by the Centennial State - director ofFrozenJennifer Lee , her character was recast to Evan Rachel Wood withinFrozen 2because the demands of the character had increase dramatically since the first film , which let in singing her own birdsong “ All Is Found . ”
touch on : Frozen ’s Original Ending Would ’ve Been bad
UnlikeFrozen , which primarily follow Anna and Elsa as they sputter to infer and control Elsa ’s powers , icy 2explores the world beyond Arendelle and enclose the mythos of theFrozenuniverse , including the five elementals spirits , the Enchanted Forest , and themythical river Ahtohallan , all of which are established through Iduna ’s backstory . Since Iduna ’s connectedness to elemental magic is a primal plot of ground point withinFrozen 2,it ’s a second foreign that Iduna almost does n’t seem to understand magic withinFrozen .
Frozen 2 Reveals Queen Iduna Lived With Magic Before
ThroughoutFrozen 2 , it ’s give away that Queen Iduna was formerly expose to the magic in nature produce by the elemental spirits of globe , fire , water , and air during her childhood . When Anna and Elsa met the remaining Northuldra people in the Enchanted Forest , they learn that their mother was also Northuldra since her scarf belonged to one of the old Northuldra family , agree to Honeymaren ( Rachel Matthews ) . Between Agnarr ’s bedtime storey about his experience inthe Enchanted Forestand the memories Elsa uncovers at Ahtohallan , it ’s unveil that Iduna , as a unseasoned Northuldra girl , used to spiel with the wind sprightliness Olaf ( Josh Gad ) later names “ Gale , ” and that she saved Agnarr with Gale ’s assistance .
Since Iduna grew up in the Enchanted Forest , interact peacefully with the elemental spirits , and even had a personal friendly relationship with the current of air spirit Gale , she distinctly has positive memories interacting with magic in the past tense . With this in mind , Iduna would ’ve been a rare human expert on elemental magic due to her firsthand knowledge , which does n’t align with one of the earliest scenes fromFrozenwhen Agnarr and Iduna consult the rock trolling after Anna and Elsa ’s accident .
Related : How Frozen ’s Hans Broke A Disney Villain Rule
Queen Iduna Doesn’t Understand Magic — or Elsa
The opening tantrum ofFrozendoesn’t make sense when paired with Iduna ’s backstory feature inFrozen 2 . When Elsa incidentally injures Anna with her powers , Agnarr express , “ I know where we have to go , ” consults an sometime book onScandinavian folklorefeaturing information about the stone troll and how they ’ve been known to heal humans of magic hex , and grabs a function which guide to their location , which suggests that he ’s the parent who knows more about magic . While Iduna has had more personal experience with elementary trick , as is show inFrozen 2 , Iduna takes on more of a supporting role during Anna and Elsa ’s stroke and stay hushed during the whole scene . Since she watch Agnarr ’s Pb during the crisis , this makes it seem as if Iduna has n’t had much experience with magic and does n’t understand it as well as Agnarr .
While this scene fromFrozencoupled with Iduna ’s backstory could create a game pickle , or else , it ’s also possible that Iduna simply did n’t understand Elsa ’s conjuring trick in especial . Within theFrozenuniverse , the use of primary legerdemain seems to be fairly rarefied amongst humankind , which is observable when Agnarr and Iduna go to the stone troll , a group of elemental organism , for assistance when Anna is injured instead of a human versed in magic . As a member ofthe Northuldra kin group , Iduna has only ever interacted with the spirits of the Enchanted Forest since their elementary abilities have been ingratiated into the Northuldra path of aliveness . While Elsa ’s conjuration is also found on the elements , her ability are a type of magic Iduna has never experience before since none of the Northuldra could master illusion themselves , which may partially explain why she claim a backseat within the panorama .
Why Queen Iduna Feared Elsa’s Magic (Despite Grand Pabbie’s Warning)
King Agnarr and Queen Iduna ’s chemical reaction to Grand Pabbie ’s ( Ciarán Hinds ) warning inFrozenalso does n’t line up with Iduna ’s chronicle with elemental legerdemain fromFrozen 2 . When Agnarr and Iduna visitthe rock trolls , Grand Pabbie warns Elsa that fearfulness will be her enemy if she does n’t acquire to control her powers , which is why Agnarr and Iduna decide to isolate Elsa in the palace away from the citizens of Arendelle . While Grand Pabbie ’s message could be interpreted in multiple means , it ’s reveal at the end ofFrozenthat Elsa ’s own fearfulness of her tycoon was the truthful enemy that Grand Pabbie warned her against . However , give that Iduna had such a positive experience with magic in her puerility , it seems unlikely that Iduna would teach Elsa that the good elbow room to assure her magic is to inhibit it . Since Iduna knows firsthand that magic can be a beautiful affair , it ’s surprising that Iduna never taught Elsa not to fear her magic .
Related : Frozen 2 : Every ' 80s consultation In " Lost In The Woods "
Alternatively , Iduna ’s action inFrozencould be explained when viewing Grand Pabbie ’s warning from a different perspective . Agnarr and Idunaappear to translate Grand Pabbie ’s warning to intend that the people of Arendelle may one day twist on Elsa because of their fright of her powers . While Iduna could ’ve similarly speak out about how witching should n’t be fear but rather celebrated to the world , she would ’ve had to unveil her own past history with trick to do so , as well as the fact that she was Northuldran . At the fourth dimension , the Northuldra masses were probably still considered enemy of Arendelle given the unexplained battle in the Enchanted Forest between the Arendellians and the Northuldrans . If the people of Arendelle had learned that not only was their pouf bear on to Arendelle ’s enemies but that Elsa ’s magic had a connection to them as well , it may have increased their concern of her , which is why Iduna kick the bucket along with the thought to hide Elsa ’s thaumaturgy to begin with .
SinceFrozen 2wasn’t planned during the yield ofthe first film , it seems likely that the at odds scenes from the two films involving Iduna ’s history with magic together create aFrozen 2plot hole ; however , many of the events ofFrozenwouldn’t have occurred without it . If Iduna had learn Elsa not to fear her magic , Anna never would ’ve had to sacrifice herself to save her sister from Prince Hans ( Santino Fontana ) , and it would ’ve rob Elsa and Anna of the minute that strengthened their sisterlike bail , which is the bosom of the entire franchise .
More : quick-frozen 2 : What The Cast Looks Like In Real Life
