Related
Shortly after the release of the firstFantastic Beastsmovie in 2016 , fans hypothecate that , like Credence , Ariana Dumbledore had been an Obscurial . Now , with the dismissal ofSecrets of Dumbledore , this possibility has been confirmed . Ariana had been depict inDeathly Hallowsas a riotous young girl who had tried to repress her power , only to find them blow up out of her control . The estimation of an Obscurus had not yet been described , but Jude Law ’s version of Albus Dumbledore last said the Holy Scripture in tie-up with his late sister .
However , not every fan theory will ever be proven correct , no matter how much they make sense . J.K. Rowling leave several aspects of the write up inHarry Potterunexplained , leaving audience to guess why sure characters did what they did . While many of these fan - made ideas leave out the mark , others line up perfectly with Rowling ’s tale . Rankershared several of these hypothesis from fans on Reddit and asked audience to vote on the ones they found the most probable to be true .
Note : Ranker list are fan - vote , live , and continue to fall votes , so some rankings may have change after this publishing .
Ron & Hermione Are Meant To Parallel Harry’s Parents
RedditorCollectandRunshared a possibility that Hermione and Ron were more than just Harry ’s best Friend . As an orphan with no relatives to instruct him the globe ’s fashion , Harry should have turn out a lot worse than he did . However , Ron and Hermione made certain that was n’t the case .
Ron teach Harry about the wizarding world like a father would have , and Hermione behaved as a conscience to Harry as a female parent would . Combined with the fact that Hermione was a canny Muggle - born like Lily and Ron was a snarky pure - blood like James , this hypothesis holds itself up sensibly well .
Dumbledore Hoped Harry Would Develop An Obscurus
An Obscurus will make grow within a untested beldam or champion when they become overly fearful of showing their powers . The hold back trick then turns inwards , creating a epenthetic being that ultimately proves fateful to the host .
Redditorsynchrodantheorized that whenDumbledore direct Harry with the Dursleys , he knew they would not support Harry ’s magic . Since Dumbledore was well aware of what those conditions could produce , it makes sense that it was part of his program . Of naturally , Harry had no choice but to live with one of Lily ’s relatives to stay protected , so it ’s potential Dumbledore just knew the peril was the only way .
As Master Of Death, Harry Can Break The Elder Wand
A major frustration with theDeathly Hallowsmovie was Harry ’s decision to break the Elder Wand . Many fans verbalise their scandalization , posit that it would not have been so gentle to snap the most powerful sceptre in the worldly concern , but RedditorSportingNerdshared a theory that has exchange some minds .
Since Harry had been the one to reunite the Deathly Hallows and was , therefore , the Master of Death , he might have been theonlyone who could break the wand . Since this never pass off in the book , it is knockout to say if this hypothesis is true , but enough fans on Ranker believe that it at least satisfies what had been considered a significant plot pickle .
Dumbledore Protected Hogwarts More Than Anyone Knew
Dumbledore received a quite a little of unfavorable judgment from fans for the casual way he endangered his students ' life . Between a series of murderous DADA instructor , taboo forests , and hold back killer magical beasts , it seemed that the Headmaster should have shown more concern rather than just givetheHarry Pottercharacters ' life lessons . Still , one possibility might explain why he barely lifted a finger .
Redditorlogouteventuallypointed out that although several students should have died due to risky events at Hogwarts , no one ever did while Dumbledore was Headmaster . The survival of several students seemed to only come down to chance . A possible explanation is that Dumbledore used some powerful patch when he became Headmaster that keeps anyone from dying on the grounds , but only he know about it .
Dumbledore Intended Harry To Fail At Occlumency
As clever as Dumbledore was , it made little sense that he would have expected Snape or Harry to make any try during their Occlumency lessons . Therefore , it could be that the man - with - a - programme had something else in mind .
RedditorOniknightshared their theory that Dumbledore know all along that the Occlumency lessons would cause Harry to further open his mind alternatively of closing it . He may have hoped that Harry ’s teenage worked up impulses would easy involve Voldemort , causing him to make an uncharacteristically irrational mistake , like die to the Ministry and revealing himself .
Harry And Ron Were Powerful Seers
Harry and Ron had very small interest in Divination , principally due to the teacher , whom everyone could recognize as a fraud . However , had they been learning under someone more qualified , they may have realized they had a natural aptitude for the subject .
Redditorminisaladfreshbelieves that Harry and Ron were prophesier that both surpassedthe summed - up skill of Professor Trelawney inHarry Potter . InPrisoner of Azkaban , the two tried to devise as many vicious anticipation as possible for their homework while express mirth off the absurd nature of the subject field . However , each of the prognostication for Harry ’s future came true . He was in danger of burns in the Triwizard Tournament , stabbed in the back by the imposter Mad - Eye Moody , and killed in the forest by Voldemort .
Cedric’s Body Didn’t Have To Touch The Portkey
Another plot hole that consultation noticed in theHarry Potterseries was Harry bring Cedric Diggory ’s torso back with him through the Portkey . In every other example , a person could only be channel if they touched a Portkey . However , the book distinctly describes how Harry had grab the cup with one hand and Cedric ’s body with the other .
Redditorthemolotovgingershared a theory that could fill this hole in the most heartbreaking way . When a necromancer uses a Portkey , any physical object they are touching come in with them ( dress , bag , etc . ) . Therefore , since Cedric ’s dead body no longer had a soul , it was only an object , not a soul .
Harry Could Have Controlled The Basilisk
InChamber of Secrets , Harry was able to gain accession to Slytherin ’s mystic chamberbecause he had gained the ability to speak to snakes when the shard of Voldemort ’s soul had latched on to him . However , when he was faced with the Basilisk itself . brain-teaser made it clear that only the inheritor of Slytherin could control it .
Redditorsherbetholmesfelt this did n’t make sense , and almost a thousand fans on Ranker correspond . Since Harry had a part of the inheritor ’s individual in his body , the Basilisk should have recognized him as another inheritor . Therefore , if Harry had only tried to recite the brute what to do , fans concord that it probably would have forge .
The Hallows Resurrected Harry
After Voldemort used the Killing Curse on Harry in the Forbidden Forest , Harry woke up in a humans that look like King ’s Cross , with Dumbledore to recognise him . The professor explained that Harry had lived because Voldemort had used Harry ’s blood to create a new body , but RedditorWippitGuudfelt there was more to it .
The fact that Harry talk to Dumbledore after being hit by the condemnation imply that Harry really was dead . However , since he had the allegiance of the Elder Wand , Ressurection Stone , and Invisibility Cloak , he was the Master of Death and could choose his destiny and either carry on to the afterlife or go back . It ’s unclear if this was what Rowling intended , but with over 1,400 votes , this theory is a safe bet .
The Dementors Had A Stronger Interest In Harry Than Others
InPrisoner of Azkaban , Harry was discomfited and humiliated by how he involuntarily oppose to the Dementors . Lupin explicate that since he had experienced so much pain in his life-time , he was a prime victim of the creatures . While this made sensory faculty , audience like RedditorThereIsBearfelt it was n’t a perfect explanation .
Since Harry was a Horcrux for an eighth of Voldemort ’s someone , it means that or else of having just one like everyone else , Harry had 1.125 of a someone . Therefore , the Dementors would have been extra interested in him as he would allow even more of a meal . alike , since Voldemort only had an eighth of a soulfulness in his body , he may have been more resistant to their power , even without a Patronus .
NEXT:10 Characters Who Made The Most Magical First Impressions harmonise To Ranker
