Related
buff ofHarry Potterare extremely passionate , and a lot of them have studied the books to the extreme , realise the characters and their need well . Redditis often a topographic point for buff of this variety to gather and share their opinion , and in a thread of late originate by userrollotar300 , many gather to discuss misconceptions about the serial publication .
Some of these misconception have deduct from the moving-picture show , and others just from vary interpretations of the text edition . What misunderstandings of the story seem to irk Redditors the most ?
Molly Is A Bad Parent To Ron
Molly Weasley has been the basic for the joke that parent are always overnice to their shaver ’s friend than to their existent children , with dozens of meme depicting the difference in how she treat Harry to her own kids . Some have taken this to the extreme , believing that Molly is a bad parent to her Ron in special .
Redditormadlymusingpresents their argument that she is n’t , saying " I think there ’s sight of evidence she loves all of her children deeply and extend that love to her kids ’ friends . I like that she ’s an imperfect parent , and I do n’t think her oversights / mistakes are because she ’s neglected Ron in any way of life . "
Quidditch Isn’t Fair
Quidditch is a puzzling game for Muggles , as its magical properties have a major effect on the game . Many have stated that the secret plan is in reality unfair because deviate broomsticks cost different amounts , so the more flush scholarly person will be able to go faster and worry less about the equipment being damaged .
Pandaprints1made the point that " perhaps a faster broom is an advantage , but equipment differences are something you see everywhere in real liveliness younker variation . " They also note that there ’s a misunderstanding on how the percentage point system works . The point about equipment difference is precise , which is why it ’s lucky that Harry received his Nimbus 2000 .
Harry Lived Due To The Resurrection Stone
The movie adaptation ofThe Deathly Hallowsdepicts Harry collecting the Resurrection Stone from the snitch , then when he is executed , it seem to bring him back to life . Some like this idea , because they consider it gives the Deathly Hallows more of an important role in the narrative .
In the books , Harry ’s road back to life is more due to the involvement of Lily Potter ’s protection thaumaturgy . UsernIBLIBnotes " The Christ’s Resurrection stone does n’t resurrect people . That ’s the whole point of it and why the 2d sidekick dies in the story . " The Harlan Stone simply allows the user to add back forms of the dead , as expose in the films when he speaks to the ghosts of his parents .
Draco Is A Victim
Draco is a controversial figure in the Wizarding World , as some consider he ’s a victim of his father ’s abuse , which rationalize many of his bad actions in the serial . The original poster suggests that Lucius was not as high-risk as he seemed , since Draco would always propose that his father would side with him , and that Lucius ' only purpose was to regain and protect him during the Battle of Hogwarts .
The case against Draco was that he ’s not actually a victim , and that he ’s just a spoiled rich kid . UserRorscachtheMightysums it up well , saying " Draco Malfoy is some sort of dupe . He ’s not . He ’s a fearful fiend , like his father , like his female parent . The whole family is stinky . "
Ron Wasn’t Smart
The movies gave the picture that Ron was a lousy student , and that he was dim , and player Rupert Grint seemed to play up this approximation for comical effect . disregardless , Grint as Ron was still one of thebest book to movie changes ofHarry Potter .
RedditorLuna8586states that " He and Harry literally got the same level and were the American equivalent of Bel students . And their bad grade were mostly in classes that they did n’t take in earnest like History of Magic and soothsaying . " Ron was a fine enough educatee , but just chose his battles sagely .
Harry Is A Weak Wizard
The idea that Harry is a subpar Wizard has spread , mainly due to him constantly being matched up with far older and more experienced opponents throughout the series . While he definitely is n’t as firm as Voldemort as the movies would make him seem , he also has a mint of natural talent .
ThisRedditorstates " he may come across as such because he is put up against wizard with far superior skills and much older than him . But , away from a few exception which were triggered by external factors , he masters pretty much any spell by observing it . " In the films , The Half - Blood Princeprobably well demonstrates his ability to learn and understand material with the compounding of his born skill .
Hermione Is The Only Smart One
Of the trio of Hermione , Harry , and Ron , there ’s a misconception that Hermione is the only one who ’s intelligent . While she ’s definitely the smartest and hardest working , Ron and Harry have their noetic feats too .
Theoriginal posterdescribes the importance of Hermione , and cite how often Harry and Ron advise they ’d never get anywhere without her , but also says " the reality is that just as she has been vital to the group they have also save her on unlike occasion . "
Draco Is As Intelligent As Hermione
There ’s no doubt that Draco Malfoy is a skilled wizard in breeding , and that he has some ingeniousness . Many have suggested though that a set of Draco ’s skill comes from natural endowment , whereas Hermione surpasses sensation like Draco or Harry due to her immense amount of prison term studying and learning .
ThisRedditorsums it up utterly , sort Hermione with wizards like Snape , saying " Hermione , Snape , Dumbledore , 3/4 Marauders , and a few others of [ sic ] are technological players . They learn the possibility and practice they build their science to often be good then [ sic ] those with sheer raw talent no matter of their own talent . "
Harry Isn’t As Close To Hermione As Ron
A common misconception that ’s hated byPotterfans is that Harry had a much strong relationship with Ron than he did with Hermione . The relationship between the two male child is well-fixed to blob , since it ’s a very visible outward-bound bromance of fun and laugh .
UserNeveranabsolutionsays " it ’s light that both friendship think the domain to him , but the dynamics are just different . " Harry and Ron have a fun - loving kinship , but Harry and Hermione have a much more serious and excited joining .
Sirius Just Sees Harry As James
One of the main percentage point from the original poster is that Sirius Black watch Harry as James , and not as his own mortal . The Redditor disagrees with the idea , and bring up some times when Sirius specifically notes Harry ’s youth and case-by-case self . Harry and Sirius ' relationship is what made Sirius one ofthe bestHarry Pottercharacters .
Some of this may come fromThe Order of the Phoenixfilm when Harry and Sirius fight off the Death Eaters , and Sirius circumstantially name to Harry by his father ’s name . Theuseralso points out " the conversation and the varsity letter Harry and Sirius send each other during the 4th book where Sirius obviously admit a fatherlike stance towards Harry " as an example of their unfeigned relationship .
NEXT:10 UK Locations Harry Potter Fans Will Recognize
