Related
TheHarry Potterfilm serial publication is one of the fewmovie adaptations of book that remain unfeigned to the reservoir cloth . Unlike the hate movie adaptations such asPercy Jackson and the Lightning ThiefandEragon , theHarry Potterfilms perfectly handle to capture the magic ( punning intended ) of the beloved book .
As with every movie adjustment , a stack of substance has to be cut due to budgetary and time restrictions ( a reason more and morebooks are being adjust into boob tube show rather than movies ) . There are many changes in theHarry Pottermovies that make sense , and just as many that do n’t .
Makes Sense - Cho tells Umbridge about Dumbledore’s Army instead of Marietta
In the novelHarry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix , Cho Chang ’s friend Marietta betrays the DA and tell apart Umbridge about the secret organization . However , in the movie adaptation , this was changed to Cho differentiate Umbridge about it under the influence of Veritaserum , a accuracy blood serum .
This was a upright edit , since the writers had to bestow some engagement between Harry and Cho , and Marietta had barely any lines , even in the books . progress to Cho the betrayer ( albeit under Sojourner Truth serum ) forwarded the plot just as well while concenter on the kinship of the principal character .
Doesn’t Make Sense - Neville The Chosen One?
InOrder of the Phoenix , Dumbledore explains to Harry that he might not even have been the Chosen One , as there was one other son who fulfilled the consideration of the Prophecy - Neville Longbottom . However , because Voldemort go after Harry and give him the scratch , it basically made him into the boy in the prophecy .
The film make no mention of this , and fans were left wonder why . Neville is such an important character , especially inDeathly Hallows , and the pic could have easily integrate this .
Makes Sense - Ludo Bagman was Cut
Ludo Bagman was a former international Quidditch participant and Ministry of Magic employee inHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire . The only reason for his presence in the Christian Bible was as sort of a comedic element and to wait on as a red herring for reader , to throw suspicion off Barty Crouch Jr.
The determination to not include him in the moviewas a sensible one , as viewers already knew Barty Crouch Jr. was alive at the start of the movie . There was plainly no reason for the lineament to live .
Doesn’t Make Sense - Harry’s Eyes
The one affair Harry has probably get word the most is " You have your mother ’s eyes . " It ’s perhaps one of the most important forcible traits of Harry , since his fleeceable eyes are the one thing that link up him to his female parent . Almost every fibre who was close to the Potters has said this to Harry .
When the movies , therefore , showed Lily with dissimilar colorful eye than Harry ’s , the buff of the series get rightly disordered , with the change even spawning many memes , and they were left question if it was so difficult for the actress to put on middleman lenses for a few scene .
Makes Sense - Dumbledore’s Backstory
Many fans were upset thatThe Deathly Hallowsmovies did n’t dig into Dumbledore ’s scandalous past as deep as the books did , but the decision to not do so made sense - the movies do a good problem of introducing the conflict between Harry and Dumbledore without call for up too much sentence .
what is more , since the books are from Harry ’s POV , readers perpetually know what is pop off on in Harry ’s mind and why he was angry at Dumbledore . This was difficult to show in the movies , and any attempt to do so would have only unnecessarily added to the runtime .
Doesn’t Make Sense - The Burning of The Burrow
The Half line Princewas drastically change and end up looking more like a stripling romance movie rather than fantasy . The motion-picture show scarcely focused on Harry and The Half Blood Prince , Slughorn ’s Potions classes , or his secret lessons with Dumbledore . One of the big change was Bellatrix and Fenrir Greyback attack the Burrow during Christmas Break .
This was believably done due to pacing , to show some action so the audience does n’t get bored , but the movie should have center more on the story rather than flesh out relationship of the characters . Character developing is crucial , but not at the price of story .
Makes Sense - Neville Gives Harry Gillyweed
InGoblet of Fire , flop before the second Triwizard Task , Harry is given Gillyweed by Dobby , which will facilitate him breathe underwater . In the movie , Neville does so or else of Dobby . The variety was a simple and effective one , as it shows Harry and Neville ’s friendly relationship and just how technical Neville is at Herbology . At the end of the movie , Barty Crouch Jr. reveals he had give Neville the thought .
The book , on the other hand , has a truly perverted and complex design in which Barty Crouch Jr. tells Neville about it , but Harry does n’t need him for help , so Crouch Jr. makes sure Dobby take in him spill the beans about Gillyweed .
Doesn’t Make Sense - Dudley’s Character Development
If JK Rowling ’s plan was to make lover detest the Dursleys , she succeeded with flying colors . The Dursleys are some of the most hated charactersin the series because of how they care for Harry . However , the books show one pocket-size act of repurchase for Dudley - he thank Harry for keep his from the Dementor and say he cares about him .
Although there was an protracted track of the Dursleys leaving , and a few edit scenes similar to the one in the Book , they were for some reason not included in the theatrical cut , leaving fans disappoint with the change , and wonder why it was n’t just keep in .
Makes Sense - Not Using Polyjuice Potion at Godric’s Hollow
Harry , Ron , and Hermione are on the run inThe Deathly Hallows , hunting down the remaining Horcruxes . In the book , they practice Polyjuice Potion to take the appearance of normal muggles . In the movie , however , they do n’t apply the potion , with the exclusion of the visit to the Ministry .
In the movie , when Harry and Hermione go to Godric ’s Hollow , they do n’t use the potion ( perverse to the book ) , and the change is appreciated - the picture is quite grievous , and watching some random stranger react to Lily and James ’s graves would n’t intimately be as worked up as watching Harry .
Doesn’t Make Sense - Tom Riddle’s origins
The one modification fans dislike the most inThe Half roue Princewas the lack of explaining Voldemort ’s backstory as well as the books did . With the exception of Dumbledore and Slughorn ’s memory , there is no computer memory about Tom Riddle ’s motivations . This modification train away a large part of Voldemort ’s origins .
The record do a not bad job of showing through memories Voldemort ’s family history , his motivation , his powers , his mental capacity , and his angle of inclination for collecting trophy , all of which serve Harry in visualize out Horcruxes and their location later on .
NEXT : Harry Potter : 10 Plot Holes That Make No good sense ( Even If You ’ve Read The record book )
