Related
TheHarry Potterbooks and movies start with a define line between safe and evilness . Harry and his friends are good , and Voldemort and his supporters are bad . However , as the series goes on , these lines become glaze over , with mass on both oddment of the spectrum put deeds suit the other side .
In the end , many characters received redemption for their misdoings . However , not all of these redemptions were satisfying or credible to audiences . As well as this , some characters that should have gotten ( or at least tried for ) buyback , did not . Redditors have ask up the discussion on which reference should have gotten a character discharge , and which redemption arc could have been better .
Draco Malfoy
By the close of the series , Harry ’s perspective of Malfoy changes considerably . He recognizes that Malfoy was the product of his bringing up , but is not forged in his individual . In theOrder of the Phoenixbook , Harry realize that he no longer detest Draco , but pitties him instead .
Draco could not wipe out Dumbledore , and he did not out Harry to his fellowship , which proved that he was n’t all big . However , RedditorJudy - Leefelt that this could not really " be considered [ redemption ] . " Fans never learn if Draco made actual change to his fashion after Voldemort ’s frustration , leaving his fictional character arc feeling incomplete . Any augury that he had learned from the events of the war , or even some acknowledgment that he had been wrong , would have gone a long way for rooter .
Dudley Dursley
Dudley excruciate Harry his entire living , until short , in the last book , he shares with Harry that he had grown to appreciate him and was grateful to him for saving his spirit . Harry , and readers , were surprised by this , but the tale moves on and Dudley is never mentioned again .
In the motion-picture show , Dudley does n’t even get the unsatisfactory redemption he realize in the book , since his apologyscene was deleted from theDeathly Hallowsmovie . Harry just simply watches him leave . RedditorJudy - Leefelt that the " line of partition remained entire " between Harry and his cousin in both translation , lead audiences unsure about what their kinship might look like in the future . Dudley had just learned to mistreat Harry from his parents , and an arc that explore his realization that his parent had been wrong would have been interesting to see .
Severus Snape
Snape did get redemption for choosing to link Voldemort . He deep regretted that his alternative resulted in Lily ’s death , and he put himself through extreme danger to protect her son . Ultimately , he die carrying out this foreign mission , examine himself to be a paladin inHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows .
This redemption left a fortune of public debate among devotee though . " [ Snape ] owns up to some of his heavy mistakes , while also not caring about others , " direct out oneReddit user . Snape regale Harry very below the belt throughout the serial publication , bordering on actual abuse . The fact that this was forgiven simply because he had have it off Lily was not agreeable to fans . Instead , a redemption arc that admit him realizing that his treatment of Harry had not been fair and rationalize for it would have been more impactful and would have made his forfeiture all the more touching .
Regulus Black
Regulus Black is Sirius ’s brother who conjoin the Death Eaters when he finished school . When he realized that he did not aline with Voldemort ’s morality , he tried to escape his ranks and work to take Voldemort down from the interior .
This story was only discovered by Harry through the varsity letter he left in station of Voldemort ’s Horcrux , and through the account of Kreacher . No one who knew Regulus in life ever memorise that he had turned to the side of skillful , leading RedditorAmEndevomTagto sense that he never " really had a redemption arc at all . " If more data had been unveil that usher Regulus ’s battle to come to the true statement , or if Sirius had ever even talked more about his buddy ’s journeying , his repurchase arc would have palpate more complete .
Petunia Dursley
Harry Potterfans are often confused about Petunia ’s impression towards her sis , Lily . She treated Harry awfully , often stating that she had hated her " freak " baby . However , inDeathly Hallows , Harry learned that Petunia had been jealous of her sister , and had once loved her dearly .
The revelation hinted at a possible salvation , but it never happened on the Sir Frederick Handley Page or screen door . RedditorMetalKeirSolidwas disappointed by this , feeling that even a " speck of good or heart , " should have been include . Petunia never had an opportunity to make up for how she treat her babe ’s son , even though the story could have benefitted from it .
Peter Pettigrew
Pettigrew was a purelydespicable and ruthless character inHarry Potter . Everything he did was out of ego - preservation , and he is the verbatim reason for James and Lily ’s deaths . Despite this , Harry once spared his life , result in a debt that would subsequently result in Pettigrew ’s end .
Pettigrew hesitated to bolt down Harry because of this debt , and the silver mitt gift to him by Voldemort strangled him . But RedditorAmata69felt that this dry destruction did n’t leave the wallop that it could have . " I think that he should have been more than just a hanger - on who wander everyone . " A larger act of redemption , like actively taste to spare Harry , would have made his death even more impactful and would have put up better to his fiber arc .
James Potter
Any time Harry witness memories of James in shoal , he is behaving like a vicious bully . It becomes clear why Snape would have detest him , but there is very footling to excuse why Lily run low from despising him as well to marrying him .
Harry struggle with his perspective of his Church Father , worrying that he had not been a adept soul . In theOrder of the Phoenixbook , Lupin but assure him that he had changed . RedditorShuaib1220said , " if you ’re gon na tell me he changed to a better somebody , then I need to see some of his internal struggles . " Harry might have been satisfied with Lupin ’s solution , but audiences mat a detailed buyback arc would have help them to accept Jame ’s variety .
Percy Weasley
Percy was never very likeable , but when he cut out contact with his family and chose to support the Ministry against Harry , he fructify a whole new ( very dispirited ) bar . In the movies , none of Percy ’s motivation is ever explain , and therefore a repurchase spark was totally out of the question .
In theDeathly Hallowsbook , though , Percy returns to his family and apologizes , help them to fight down the Death Eaters . Even this redemption did n’t feel like enough to Redditors likeSufferagette , who thought that Percy " do back to his family " should have started much rather in the book and developed over time . Instead , Percy ’s sudden change of heart felt less like a salvation arc and more like a last resort .
Hermione Granger
Hermione remained firm on the side of good throughout the intact serial in both the books and movies . However , the way that she treats the mass she disagrees with has rubbed some fans the awry way . In theDeathly Hallowsbook particularly , she frequentlyrefused to listen to Harry ’s instincts , instead rudely dismiss him altogether .
RedditorFaerie_Queen_felt that Hermione " deserved to be call out more often " for her mistreatment of her friends . Instead , even when she was evidence to be wrong , nothing ever happened . A redemption arc that involved Hermione apologizing after she had been try wrong , and learning to open her mind to other masses ’s opinions would have made her a much better character .
NEXT : What Wizarding World Career You Would Have Based On Your Zodiac
