Related
When theHarry Potterbooks were first liberate , Dumbledore seemed like a very benevolent and skillful mentor reference in the first few years Harry was at Hogwarts . However , the terminal leger revealed that Dumbledore was a much more complex character than he seemed with a rather saturnine past . While Dumbledore might still have want secure thing for the existence , he was n’t always ethical , and he made some huge misunderstanding .
Because of Dumbeldore ’s power and influence in the wizarding world , many of his option had far - hit impacts and consequences on other hoi polloi . And , while he did n’t always mean to do harm , he did still make some bad choices .
Leaving Harry with the Dursleys
This is one choice Dumbledore made that he might have meant with dear intent , but it ’s still rather mess up up when you analyze it .
While Dumbledore wants Harry to have wizard aegis from Voldemort , he also opt to have him survive withabusive guardian where he was trim off from any kindness or support . He was neglect and treated horribly , and Harry ’s trauma does n’t get talk about enough .
Keeping his distance from Harry in Order of the Phoenix
A luck of Dumbledore ’s worst option have to do with Harry and how he treated him . Given how much responsibility he set on Harry and the encumbrance he knew Harry carried , he definitely was n’t always there for him as he should have been . While he might have ignored Harry in an attempt to keep him safe from Voldemort , this just backlash .
Harry was proceed through a sight of things , and he needed Dumbledore ’s support . Maybe with his aid , Sirius would n’t have ended up beat .
He let horrible things happen at Hogwarts
While Dumbledore at first might have seemed like someone you ’d want as your Headmaster or leader at school , he really was n’t good at his chore . He was supposed to be in explosive charge of protecting the school and its students , but he was always gone when the shoal need him most .
Given how much Dumbledore always seems to acknowledge , it seems unknown he would forsake the school at so many points .
Letting Snape kill him
This is a bit of a complicated point because it can also be argued that Dumbledore made the veracious decision here . He was trying to save Draco which was a very admirable goal , but by saving Draco and sacrifice himself , he was also leaving Harry alone to fight Voldemort .
Without Dumbledore , thing could have gone much worse for Harry , and Voldemort might never have been defeated . But , at the same time , it was a moral quandary .
Not doing much about the Chamber of Secrets
This is a specific example of a way in which Dumbledore did n’t protect the students as he should have . Given that he was a professor when Moaning Myrtle was kill by Slytherin ’s giant , he should have known the hazard and close down the school day immediately .
He was reckless and careless to leave Hogwarts open while pupil were being assault , and this top to Ginny being taken into theChamber of Secrets .
Not telling Harry that he himself was a Horcrux
Dumbledore was always keeping selective information from Harryuntil he thought he was older enough . While he might have made excuse for this , afford all of the things Harry had carry through and all Dumbeldore expected of him , this was insufferable .
Even after finally telling Harry the truth of the prophecy and Horcruxes , he still did n’t differentiate Harry that he suspected Harry was one , too . This made it so Harry had to project this out on his own .
Not taking responsibility for his part in Ariana’s death
While Dumbledore made some fairly glaring mistake during Harry ’s meter at school , he made some even bad ones when he was younger . His participation with Grindelwald and the Dark Arts lead in some way to his sister ’s death .
And , while in camera he might have taken responsibility for this , he never let the cat out of the bag about it or really claimed these mistakes in public . This prepare him seem sneaky and manipulative .
Not stopping Grindelwald sooner
While Dumbeldore being involve with Grindelwald and his hateful , anti - Muggle rhetoric was forged enough , his decisiveness to wait to hold back him might have been even worse .
He knew he was the only one who could really stop him , but he allow free masses be harmed because of her feelings for Grindelwald . This was a vast error that deepen many other masses ’s lives .
Hiring so many unsafe professors
devote that Dumbeldore is so bright and powerful as a wizard , it ’s amazing that he ’s such a pathetic judge of character . While he did hire some good professors like Lupin , he also rent people like Lockhart and Quirrell .
And , on top of that , he also permit prof likeSnape continually ill-treatment and bully their students with no repercussions .
Expecting Harry to do so much alone
Given that Harry is the champion of the tale and that it ’s a series mean for children , Harry does way more things than any teenager would really be expected to do .
However , even while allowing for some suspension of disbelief , it ’s arduous to justifyhow much Dumbledore rent Harry do alone . He could have offer a hatful more work force - on helper either through himself or through the help of other adult .
NEXT:15 Things From The Harry Potter Series That Have n’t Aged Well
