Related
Remus Lupin might not be a main character from theHarry Potterseries , but he is well - make love by rooter especially hold he really only boast in one book . He ’s often considered one of , if not the , good Hogwarts prof , and his past as one of the Marauders makes him especially interesting .
While Remus Lupin is overall a full quality who was a extremity of both iterations of the Order of the Phoenix , he ’s not perfect . He ’s got many positive traits and does many proficient things , but he also makes some mistakes and has his own personality flaws . Here are his most influential bad choices .
Running around Hogwarts in his werewolf form
Lupin was bitten and became a loup-garou when he was only four years sure-enough , and pay that the wizarding world is so discriminatory against werewolves , he believably image he would have no friends when Dumbledore welcome him to come to Hogwarts .
So , it makes sense he might have a hard time sticking up to these Friend . While luckily their determination to course around the yard with a full - fledged loup-garou did n’t lead to any tragedy , it was still dangerous .
Letting Snape and Sirius fight all the time
The chronicle of the relationship between Snape and the Marauders is long and rather complicated . While Snape was n’t just a victim , James and Sirius were n’t always the grinder either . Once both Snape and Sirius were in the newfangled Order of the Phoenix , these two keep on to fight . Lupin was in a position to try and end this , but he never really intervene .
This in part would conduct to Sirius feeling more and more reckless and goaded by Snape .
Not being more active in Harry’s life
One of the strangest thing about Lupin is how he never really tries to get through Harry at all before becoming a Hogwarts professor . founder that he was really penny-pinching friends with James and Lily , it seems unusual he never really tried to check up on their only son given that they both died tragically .
Then , even after he meets Harry , he does n’t do all that much to be a mentor to him after leaving Hogwarts . This definitely could have made a heavy departure in Harry ’s lifetime particularly after Sirius died .
Issues with his relationship with Tonks
Lupin ’s kinship with Tonks had a deal of yield and pitfalls from the source . Lupin was hesitating to be in a romantic human relationship as he worry about the brand colligate with being with a werewolf . Many fans also find their human relationship reasonably developing and mismatched .
However , in terminus of canon , Lupin made a mistake by not handling his family relationship with Tonks better at the start . He stop her heart reasonably which contribute to her overall imprint .
Seeing Pettigrew on the map but doing nothing
This point is somewhat complicated because it ’s a bit of a plothole . Seeing as how Lupin took the function from Harry and looked at it , it seems unusual that he would n’t have noticed Pettigrew on the single-valued function before the Nox where they all went into the Whomping Willow .
If he did see Pettigrew , he should have said something about it earlier on .
Joining the Battle of Hogwarts
In many ways , it ’s hard to judge this conclusion as a mistake . Asmembers of the Order of the Phoenixwho had committed their life to fight Voldemort , it make gumption that Lupin and Tonks would join this struggle .
However , not that it ’s at all their fracture , this decision did lead to both of their tragical and untimely deaths . It feels in some way like at least one of them should have stayed behind give how young Teddy was at the clock time .
Letting Peter Pettigrew get away
At the end ofHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban , both Sirius and Lupin need to kill Pettigrew for what he did . Harry stops them because he wants there to be test copy that Sirius was n’t murdered , and , while this did make sense , thing did n’t plow out that way .
Given that Sirius and Lupin knew Pettigrew was foxy and able to turn into a rat , it would have been proficient if they had at least incapacitate him in some way . The fact that they let him be witting as they brought him up to Hogwarts was a huge risk that guide to disaster .
Not sticking up to James and Sirius
James and Sirius were both pop students with strong personalities , and they thought they were above the rule . Lupin was more grounded and measured , but he want to keep being their close protagonist and worried about sticking up to them .
However , there were definitely second he should have stopped them from formula - breaking specially when it come to drive their treatment of Snape too far .
Not telling Dumbledore about the Marauder’s Map
While it ’s debatable whether Lupin would have noticed Pettigrew on the mapping before , the Sojourner Truth is that he sleep together about the Marauder ’s Map and that Sirius already had knowledge on how to sneak into Hogwarts because of it . He acknowledge he should tell Dumbledore about this , but he still was too worried about letting Dumbledore down by admitting the truth of the Marauder ’s youthful mistake .
This decision limit in action all the events of thePrisoner of Azkaban .
Trying to leave behind a pregnant Tonks
While Lupin overall seems to be a good person with substantial ethics , he let his care get the serious of him when he believe Tonks and their unborn child will be better off without him . While being worried and having guilt over this might be intelligible , it still was n’t acceptable for Lupin to abandon them and attempt to get out with Harry , Ron , and Hermione .
This for sure must have impacted Tonks and Lupin ’s kinship , and it definitely alter how Harry thought about Lupin .
NEXT : Harry Potter : 10 thing That Make No Sense About Remus Lupin
