Related
In a late audience , Daisy Ridley confirmed whatStar Warsfans had long surmise , that there were no substantial plan for her character Rey . J.J. Abrams apparently did n’t make up one’s mind on Rey ’s backstory as Emperor Palpatine ’s granddaughter until halfway through makingThe Rise of Skywalker . The thespian got a phone call every few twenty-four hours say her that her eccentric was being drastically changed .
Making Rey ’s stock important seemed like a direct reply to the fan outrage following Rian Johnson ’s “ cypher ” divulge inThe Last Jedi . One interesting detail provided by Ridley was that Abrams ’ initial design was to disclose Rey as a Kenobi . This could ’ve conduct to some major changes inThe Rise of Skywalker .
It Would Give Kylo Ren More Of A Reason To Lie To Her
Revealing Rey ’s line of descent to be a significantStar Warscharacter inThe Rise of Skywalkerseemed to be a deliberate endeavor to retconThe Last Jedi ’s revelation that her parents were “ nobodies . ” If Rey was a Kenobi , Kylo Ren would have more of a reason to lie about her lineage .
He could ’ve narrate her she was a Palpatine to sway her over to the dark side , but he ’d have a good ground to cover up her connection toarguably the greatest Jedi who ever lived .
Rey’s Vision In The Force Awakens Would Make More Sense
There ’s no more egregious example of J.J. Abrams ’ mind - numbing “ mystery box ” storytelling than the visual sensation that Rey has when she first advert Anakin ’s lightsaber in Maz Kanata ’s cellar inThe Force Awakens . This imaginativeness is just an eclectic mix of audio and TV clips , with Abrams throwing all his random ideas at the screen and seeing what would stick .
The first interpreter that Rey hears in this vision is that of Obi - Wan Kenobi , telling her , “ Rey , these are your first step . ” If she turned out to be related to him , this sight would make some belittled semblance of sense .
Palpatine Might Not Have Returned At All
While it was a joy to see Ian McDiarmid back in the role of Emperor Palpatine and he made for a muchbetter villain than Snoke , not a destiny about his return inThe Rise of Skywalkerreally worked . From the moment Poe says , “ Somehow … Palpatine has rejoin , ” it ’s hard to take anything in the movie badly .
If Rey was a Kenobi , she ’d have no pauperism to face Palpatine and he might not have been brought back from the dead at all .
Obi-Wan’s Force Ghost Could’ve Made An Appearance
Instead of every past Jedi randomly popping up in Rey ’s nous to give her Holy Scripture of boost , Obi - Wan ’s Force ghost could ’ve seem to guide her if she was a descendant of his .
Since Obi - Wan ’s wraith was take on by Alec Guinness in the original trilogy , it might ’ve been strange to see Ewan McGregor as his ghost inThe wage increase of Skywalker . But fans would n’t kick if they fetch to see him in the purpose of Obi - Wan again .
There Would Be No Need For That Stupid “Rey Skywalker” Moment
The ending ofThe Rise of Skywalkeris really stupid . It would ’ve been unsatisfying as the conclusion of any movie , let alone the terminal moments of a nine - movie saga that fans have been stick with for over 40 years .
Rey adopt the name Skywalker felt really forced . If she did n’t finger the need to outdistance herself from the Palpatine name , then it might not have happened .
Chewbacca’s Horrible Fake-Out Death Wouldn’t Have Happened
Midway throughThe Rise of Skywalker , Rey accidentally destroys a First Order shipping that she believe Chewbacca is on . Seconds subsequently , it ’s revealed that Chewie is actually alive . This removes all the suspense from the situation . Rey ’s grief has no weight , because we know it ’s misplaced .
If Rey was n’t a Palpatine , this Force lightning moment would n’t have bechance and Chewie ’s stupid phoney - out death would n’t exist .
Kenobi Parentage Might’ve Been Easier To Explain
The Palpatine connection was difficult forThe boost of Skywalkerto explain . First , the movie had to explain how Palpatine returned , which it did n’t . Then , it had to excuse how he had nipper who had kids , and how Rey ended up being give up on Jakku , which was sweep over with some undefined murmurings about cloning .
Explaining that Obi - Wan fathered a child while he was view over Luke on Tatooine would ’ve been a mountain easier – and it would ’ve opened upthe storytelling possibilities for Disney+ ’s upcoming Obi - Wan series .
Satine Could’ve Been Rey’s Grandmother
ThroughoutThe Clone Wars , it was intemperately implied that Obi - Wan had a forbidden relationship with Satine . He also told Luke in the original trilogy that he “ was ” a Jedi , suggest that he no longer followed the tenets of the Jedi religion .
If Satine was Rey ’s grandmother , then Rey would ’ve been part Mandalorian , which would ’ve been infinitely more interesting than being a Palpatine with ungovernable Force lightning .
The Movie Might’ve Actually Featured “Duel Of The Fates”
Colin Trevorrow ’s rejected book forEpisode IXwas reportedly titledDuel of the Fates , key out afterthe iconic John Williams trackthat play during Obi - Wan and Qui - Gon ’s lightsaber duel with Darth Maul inThe Phantom Menace .
Disney used “ Duel of the Fates ” inThe Rise of Skywalker ’s drone to get fans excite , but did n’t really boast it in the flick . If Rey had been a Kenobi , perhaps the film producer would ’ve actually used the track .
A Kenobi Saving A Skywalker From The Dark Side Would Make A Beautiful Ending For The Saga
The tragedy ofRevenge of the Sithis that Obi - Wan ca n’t bring through his padawan Anakin from falling to the dark side , soak up the galaxy into long time of darkness .
The conflict at the nitty-gritty ofThe boost of Skywalkeris Rey ’s quest to convey Ben Solo back to the idle side . A Kenobi saving a Skywalker from the dark side , doing what her granddad never could , would ’ve bring the whole saga full circle . In the wise row of George Lucas , it ’s like verse , they rhyme .
NEXT : Star war : The hike Of Skywalker — 10 Plot Points From The Last Jedi That J.J. Abrams Ignored
