Related
During the product ofStar Wars : The Last Jedi , writer - director Rian Johnson had such a beneficial time that he pitched a separateStar Warstrilogy to Lucasfilm – one that would ask entirely new grapheme in a entirely dissimilar part of the galaxy – that he was set to begin work on after the release ofEpisode VIII .
However , exploitation of Johnson’sStar Warstrilogy came grinding to a stop whenThe Last Jediirreparably divided the fan baseand the managing director was termed “ Ruin Johnson ” by a very outspoken minority . Entrusting three tentpoles to Johnson now would be a risk for Lucasfilm , but it might be a risk worth taking .
Should: Star Wars Desperately Needs New Stories
After theStar Warssequel trilogy used the nostalgic iconography of the original trilogy as a crutch and both “ Anthology ” picture , Rogue OneandSolo , went back to the well of the comparatively short period betweenEpisode IIIandEpisode IV , the vast , unlimited scope of theStar Warsuniverse urgently needs new stories .
The saga ’s timeline spans thousand of years . Johnson ’s trilogy reportedly has nothing to do with the Skywalkers . He can finally set out to severalise new storey on the big screen in the Disney era .
Shouldn’t: The Last Jedi Was A Trainwreck
WhileThe Last Jediisn’t of necessity a big flick – for all intents and purposes , it ’s well - made , and it ’s straight to Johnson ’s vision – it was a immense disappointment for a lot ofStar Warsfans .
From the word-painting of Luke Skywalker as a bitter try murderer toLeia ’s uncanny Force trajectory through spaceto the unneeded detour to Canto Bight to the smacking - in - the - face answers to questions about Snoke ’s identity and Rey ’s parentage , Johnson let down a muckle of fans and should probably leave the franchise alone from now on .
Should: Johnson’s Vision Of The Star Wars Myth Deserves A Second Chance
When Johnson was engage to write and directThe Last Jedi , he was determined to not give sports fan what they wanted . The director had his own take on theStar Warsmythos that deconstruct and challenged the traditional tale of valor .
This did n’t really work forThe Last Jedi , because its primary function was as the middle chapter in the subsequence trilogy and Johnson ’s story did n’t line up withThe Force Awakensor set up an exciting coda . But it could crop for an unrelated narration .
Shouldn’t: Other Directors Are Better-Suited To Star Wars
There are tidy sum of directors who are considerably - suited to theStar Warsuniverse than Rian Johnson . The franchise needs a filmmaker with a play sensibility and experience figure out with humor , spectacle , and big ensembles .
or else of afford three movies to Johnson , Lucasfilm should give movies to Guillermo del Toro , Matthew Vaughn , Patty Jenkins , Edgar Wright , James Gunn , and any of the other promising film producer working right now .
Should: It’s About Time Disney Made A Star Wars Trilogy With A Roadmap
When the filmmakers have a roadmap for the news report from the beginning , Star Warstrilogies can be attractively tell apart three - part stories . George Lucas examine that with both the original and prequel trilogies , which each tell an epical space opera from beginning to end .
The sequel trilogy evince what occur with the other method acting – fumbling through the dark and hop it figure out itself out along the direction – and it was a catastrophe . It ’s about time Disney madeaStar Warstrilogywith a plan .
Shouldn’t: Three Movies Are A Big Commitment
Three picture show are a huge dedication . It ’s one thing to entrust aStar Warstrilogy to George Lucas , but any other director’sStar Warsmovie is essentially fan fiction .
If Rian Johnson do the first installment in his trilogy and devotee nem con hate all his Modern characters and storylines , what ’ll go on to the next two movies ? It might be best for Lucasfilm to takeStar Warsprojects one movie at a metre .
Should: There Are Tons Of Eras In The Timeline To Explore
Although the Clone Wars and the rise of the Empire have been encompass by tons of dissimilar stories , there are a lot of era intheStar Warstimeline that still have n’t been explored in live - action movies .
From the Old Republic to the High Republic to the Hundred - Year dark to the New Sith Wars , there ’s deal of fertile ground on which Rian Johnson can severalise new narrative .
Shouldn’t: There Are Enough Star Wars Movies In Development As It Is
Disney is taking a break of serve from releasingStar Warsmovies for a while afterThe climb of Skywalkerto give disappointed fans a chance to like the franchise again before have new stuff to contain out .
But there ’s already plenty ofStar Warsmovies in ontogenesis without jam a whole new trilogy on top . Kevin Feige ’s producing aStar Warsmovie ; J.D. Dillard ’s direct aStar Warsmovie;Taika Waititi ’s direct aStar Warsmoviethat he ’s writing with1917 ’s Krysty Wilson - Cairns – it ’s enough already ; see how those do first .
Should: Johnson’s A Great Filmmaker
WhileThe Last Jedihad a litany of problems , there ’s no denying that Rian Johnson is a enceinte film maker . He directedLooperandKnives Out , which were both fantastic , and helm two ofBreaking Bad ’s okay episode : “ Fly ” and “ Ozymandias . ”
Although he ’s currently working on a new Benoit Blanc mystery , if Johnson ever gets around to hisStar Warstrilogy , there ’s a chance it could turn out terrific .
Shouldn’t: Star Wars Fans Can’t Agree On Him
SomeStar Warsfans lovedThe Last Jedi , but at least as many detest it . tolerate Rian Johnson to make three wholeStar Warsmovies would fundamentally be an intentional move to further divide the enfranchisement ’s lover foundation .
Unlike fear directors like Jon Favreau and Deborah Chow and Dave Filoni , Star Warsfans ca n’t nem con agree that Johnson is awful .
NEXT : Star war : The upgrade Of Skywalker — 10 Plot level From The Last Jedi That J.J. Abrams Ignored
