Related
Even thoughAnakin Skywalkeralmost leave theJedi Orderwhen he was just a Padawan , he would have still fallen to the dark side just the same , mean theStar Warssaga would have remained a calamity . Born on the desert - world of Tatooine , Anakin Skywalker was destined to bring balance to the Force . It ’s unclear how much of that portion is fix ; theprophecy of the Chosen Oneis millennium old , but its wording is broad and leaves a lot of room for interpretation . It ’s quite possible that , at sure fundamental minute in his life , Anakin could have choose a different path .
One such moment is recite in Charles Soule and Marco Checchetto’sObi - Wan & Anakinminiseries , set a few days after the events ofStar war : Episode I - The Phantom Menace . In this comic Anakin has already constructed his own lightsaber , but in his heart of hearts he does n’t feel like he fits in with the Jedi . A conversation with Chancellor Palpatine reenforce this horse sense , and he declare his intention to quit the Jedi Order - even handing over his lightsaber to Obi - Wan in a profoundly symbolic act . Anakin reconsiders after one last mission , which imply he never learn the trueness : that Obi - Wan has decided to follow Anakin if he leaves the Jedi . As far as Obi - Wan is concern , his vow to Qui - Gon Jinnto train Anakin , get along what may , supersedes even his oaths as a Jedi .
Related : What If Qui - Gon Beat Darth Maul ( & Trained Anakin ) In The Star Wars Prequels
All this naturally raises the interrogation of just what would have find if Anakin and Obi - Wan had indeed leave the Order . The galaxy would certainly have been different , for the duo were destined to become two of the great heroes of the Clone Wars , even if their taradiddle did have a tragic final stage . But , amazingly , by this point it ’s likely Anakin ’s ultimate fate - his fall to the dark side - was sealed .
Obi-Wan Could Never Fill The Void In Anakin’s Heart
The core problem is that Obi - Wan Kenobi could never take the void in Anakin Skywalker ’s heart . Anakin farm up with a desperate desire for a forefather - figure , which is why Qui - Gon Jinn is capable to have such a profound influence on Anakin ’s lifespan even though they only expend a few days together ; Qui - Gon promises to be the beginner - flesh Anakin never had . Obi - Wan is a pale replacement , particularly because at first his heart is n’t in it ; he mentors Anakin out of a gumption of responsibility to his strike Master , not because he believe in Anakin himself . What ’s more , at sure gloomy moments Obi - Wan would sure think back that theJedi Council did n’t require to develop Anakin , and marvel if they ’d made the right call rather than Qui - Gon . All this intend Anakin and Obi - Wan ’s first few geezerhood as Master and Apprentice are tumultuous ones , with the two fight to bond . This is on the button why Palpatine is able to get so snug to Anakin ; he promises to be the begetter - physical body the son has longed for .
The relationship between Anakin and Obi - Wan would n’t be any good in a timeline where the two leave the Jedi Order . However much Obi - Wan might attempt to hide it , there would always be a part of his heart that resents the male child who essentially forced him out of the Jedi Order . What ’s more , he would fight to educate Anakin to be anything other than a Jedi , simply because that is the only agency Obi - Wan knows ; although Qui - Gon made him aware of other Force traditions , even ancient Jedi propheciesand beliefs the Jedi desolate , Obi - Wan never really commits to those fashion . The Jedi Code provides structure to Obi - Wan ’s life , and he would n’t bed how to teach Anakin apart from it .
It ’s interesting to note theObi - Wan & Anakincomic suggests there would be one major difference between the Anakin and Obi - Wan of this timeline and the main one ; they would n’t have lightsabers . The lightsaber is more than just a weapon ; a Jedi bonds with the kyber crystal contained within the blade , and it serve as a muscular prick for speculation . Losing his lightsaber would leave Obi - Wan bereft , and he may even struggle to connect to the Force without it . This would potentially have added another border to Obi - Wan ’s resentment .
Related : Revenge Of The Sith : Why Anakin Did n’t utilise Force Healing On Padmé
Count Dooku Could Play Palpatine’s Role
One interesting interrogative is whether or not Obi - Wan would eventually look for help training Anakin . Count Dooku of Serennowould be the most obvious campaigner ; another former Jedi , Dooku was really Qui - Gon Jinn ’s old Master , and it ’s probable that connection would eventually bring Obi - Wan and Anakin to Dooku ’s doorstep . Claudia Gray ’s novelMaster & Apprenticereveals Dooku began research the sour side almost as soon as he left the Jedi , and even hints that he had found his way to the Sith before the demise of Darth Maul . Any decision to reach out to Dooku would place Anakin in grave danger indeed . It ’s potential that in this timeline , Count Dooku would be the one who tries to become a father - build to Anakin . He would do so under the guidance of Palpatine , subtly function topush the Chosen Onetowards the coloured side , and Obi - Wan - bereft of the body structure and reinforcement of the Jedi Order - would n’t get it on what to do about it . Indeed , he may even be incognizant of it .
Anakin & Padmé Would Still Be An Item
Meanwhile , one major modification is that Anakin and Padmé would plausibly get together a lot earlier . Padmé Amidala always kept track of the foreign Jedi who saved her hoi polloi from the Trade Federation , and she ’d undoubtedly find out he had left the Jedi Order . It ’s impossible to reckon any scenario where the Force does n’t take Anakin and Padmé together , and in this timeline their relationship would be very different . In the actual timeline , Anakin becomes rupture between two adherence : his attachment to the Jedi on the one hand , and to Padmé on the other . But in this timeline , he would n’t demand to choose between those two attachments , for he would n’t remain with the Jedi long enough to become bind to them . The family relationship between Anakin and Padmé would be swift , passionate - and , importantly , conducted out in the open .
Padmé may not be the only loved one Anakin gains in this timeline , though . When Anakin begins live visions of his female parent ’s fate on Tatooine , he would n’t be held back by the stenosis of the Jedi Code ; he ’d head straight there , whether Obi - Wan approve or not . And so , in this timeline , Anakin would likely wind up up living happily with his female parent and his wife . It ’s fair to sham he and Obi - Wan would party ways by this point , with Obi - Wan realizing he is no longer part of Anakin ’s world .
Anakin Would Still Fall To The Dark Side
At first coup d’oeil , it ’s tempting to see this timeline as a better one than the mainStar Warssaga - at least for Anakin . But that would be an simplism , because theClone Wars - the ultimate Jedi trap- would still break dance out . Obi - Wan would in all probability return to the Jedi to help , but Anakin ’s loyalties would be divided because of his connection to Dooku . It ’s impossible to say incisively how Palpatine would engineer Anakin ’s fall to the grim side in this timeline , but he ’d sure as shooting have a lot to work with ; Anakin ’s attachments would leave him vulnerable , and the Dark Lord of the Sith could simply organise circumstances in which his jazz ones are endanger . It ’s easy to opine a scenario where Anakin falls even more quickly than he does inStar Wars : Episode III - Revenge of the Sith , take Palpatine to speed up his design .
As the take One , Anakin Skywalker is a man of destiny . In the true , that luck is shaped as much by the galaxy he lives in as by the weight of his own choices . He thinks he is mould his future when he decides whether or not to remain with the Jedi , but he ’d still be seek after by the Sith , and he has the misfortune of living in a meter of war and turmoil . Anakin Skywalker would still fall to the non-white side , even if he ’d left the Jedi Order , and theStar Warssaga would have a note of tragedy all the same .
More : Star warfare Finally Has A Reason For Lucas ' Anakin Force Ghost Change
