Related
Lucasfilm ’s biggest error with theStar Warssequel trilogy was an overall lack of planning and forethought . George Lucas has always liked to take he had the entireStar Warssaga planned out from the scratch . Of course , that ’s something of an hyperbole ; there ’s abundant evidence he was fundamentally making it up as he went along , and frankly there ’s no disgrace in doing so . Darth Vader had a completely unlike backstorybefore he was retconned into being Luke ’s father , and Lucas only hit upon that idea when working on the 2nd draft ofThe Empire Strikes Back .
When Disney acquired Lucasfilm in 2012 , they also purchased Lucas ' scripts for the sequel trilogy . Unfortunately this proved a informant of tension between Disney and Lucas himself , because the visionary Maker believed the House of Mouse mean to make his films . " George straightaway fetch upsetas [ Kathleen Kennedy and JJ Abrams ] began to draw the plot , " then - Disney CEO Bob Iger come back in his memoir , " and it dawned on him that we were n’t using one of the stories he submitted during the negotiations . " There are still elements of Lucas ' ideas to be establish in the sequel trilogy , but on the whole Lucasfilm blazed their own trail .
Related : Star war : Everything You ask To Read To in full Understand Rise of Skywalker
In Sojourner Truth , it was an perceivable conclusion ; Lucas ' prequel trilogy had divided the fanbase , in part because he did n’t quite understand his audience . Lucas consideredStar Warsto be a children ’s franchise , which meant his plastic film were n’t needs appealing to the fans who had grown up with the original trilogy and were eager to see the saga go on . But having decided to ditch Lucas ' handwriting , Lucasfilm pushed ahead at fastness in a whole raw direction . Again , that speed is understandable , because Disney wanted to recoup some of the costs from the Lucasfilm acquisition and there had been rumors of the sequel trilogy for years . But it was a rudimentary mistake , because Lucasfilm had n’t taken the time to plan ahead - and it before long became all too evident .
Star Wars: The Force Awakens Was A JJ Abrams Mystery Box
The problem begin whenLucasfilm select JJ Abramsto become the first person after Lucas to direct aStar Warsmovie . Abrams is a talented director , but he is well known for a narrative trick he calls the " Mystery Box . " As he explained in a TED Talk , this coming to cinema - making is influenced by a box he buy at a magic store years ago that prognosticate $ 50 of magic for just $ 15 . He ’s never really open up the box , because in his thinker it present infinite potency . It could contain anything , and open up the box just removes the fervor of the enigma . He has adopted a like approach in his movies , rig up secret that he ofttimes has no intention of ever settle . The pleasure , in his view , comes from the outright possibilities .
Star state of war : The Force Awakenswas essentially one heavy secret box . Who is Rey , who were her parents , and how is this scavenger from Jakku so powerful ? Who is Supreme Leader Snoke , and how did he corrupt the son of Han and Leia , turning Ben Solo to the dark side ? Why has Luke Skywalker deport himself to the furthest corners of the galaxy ? How has the First Order arisen to peril the galaxy , and why is the New Republic so inept in its handling of them , forcing Leia to form a separate Resistance trend ? Who is Maz Kanata , how did she get her work force on the lightsaber Luke Skywalker drop off inThe Empire Strikes Back , and why did thatlightsaber " call " to Rey ? The problem is that , while Abrams seems to have had no real answers to any of these questions , as time pass on Lucasfilm would be ram to try out to give a reaction .
Lucasfilm Couldn’t Answer The Questions Abrams Raised
When Lucasfilm sign up Rian Johnson forStar state of war : The Last Jedi , he was faced with a thorny problem ; he had to develop the story , building on the foundation Abrams had lay , while head off turning his movie into a glorified Wikipedia page that answered all the unresolved questions . To that close , Johnson lead off by deciding which questions really mattered to the story of his protagonist Rey , and he strike down the one he therefore considered irrelevant . Unfortunately , he wrote his book beforeStar warfare : The Force Awakensreleased , and as such he had no way of knowing whether he ’d pick out the questions fans would be fixate upon . Snoke ’s backstory was dropped , simply because Johnson considered it irrelevant to Rey .
One question that could not be quash was the simple of them all ; who was Rey ? Abrams had toyed withmaking Rey a Kenobi , but it ’s not hard to see why Abrams adjudicate that would n’t work . It was an answer that would have meant the world to fans , but perfectly nothing to Rey , who showed no sign of ever having discover of the Jedi Master . Instead , Star warfare : The Last Jedigave Rey the last reply she was quick for ; that she was a nobody , a random Force prodigy whose parents had abandoned her . " It felt like the way to go because it ’s the hard thing that she could possibly hear,“Johnson observed as he justified his Rey reveal . " It would be the easy thing for her to be defined by , ' Yes , this is how you fit into this story — it ’s because your parent is so and so ! ' In that moment , for Kylo to be able to use that [ information ] as a tongue and twist it to try and get what he wants , felt like the most dramatically powerful option . "
Again , though , Johnson had failed to reckon on how the fans had reply to Rey as a character , and how much vivid excitement had built up about placing her in the circumstance of the generational saga . WhenStar Wars : The Last Jediwas released , the reveal turn up unbelievably controversial , and Lucasfilm wink . Star war : The salary increase of Skywalkerultimately expose Rey to be Palpatine ’s granddaughter , which sits uncomfortably withThe Last Jedi .
have-to doe with : Rey Being Obi - Wan ’s Granddaughter Is Just As Dumb As Being Palpatine ’s
Lucasfilm’s Lack Of Planning Undermined The Sequel Trilogy
Lucasfilm ’s lack of provision , and their subsequent course of instruction - correction in reception to buff response , knocked entire type spark askew . This is most noted withJohn Boyega ’s Finn , who had been marketed as a major franchise lead in the build - up toStar Wars : The Force Awakens- and was usually pictured with a lightsaber . The estimate of a former Stormtrooper becoming a Jedi who combat against the resurgent Empire is a electrifying one , and yet Finn ’s hope went unfulfilled ; he was sidelined inStar Wars : The Last Jedi , and then his Force potentiality was reduced to nothing more than a few instinctive decisions inStar warfare : The Rise of Skywalker . " Like , you guy cable knew what to do with Daisy Ridley , you knew what to do with Adam Driver,“John Boyegarightly plain late . " You knew what to do with these other people , but when it total to Kelly Marie Tran , when it came to John Boyega , you know f * * * all … They give all the nuance to Adam Driver , all the nuance to Daisy Ridley . allow ’s be honest . Daisy knows this . Adam live this . Everybody knows . I ’m not exhibit anything . "
It ’s bit by bit becoming clear only one thing was really design out in progression ; the ideaRey would become a Skywalker . The Art of Star war : The upgrade of Skywalkerdetails a confluence of the Lucasfilm Story Group in May 2014 , over a year beforeStar war : The Force Awakensreleased , and in it Pablo Hidalgo discuss this reinterpretation of what it intend to be a Skywalker . " I like the estimation that she ’s going to be our Skywalker , but she ’s not a Skywalker , " he note . " Then , for our purpose , ' the Skywalker ' is really a metaphor . It does n’t have to be something that ’s directly link to blood . " alas , even that did n’t land particularly well , because such a dramatic resolution needs to be realise , not just pass off .
-
In his bookThe Ride of a Lifetime , Bob Iger reflected that nobody remembers if a film releases late ; everybody commend if a film is uncollectible . Lucasfilm ’s approach to the subsequence trilogy was blemished from the start , because the studio did n’t take the time to reckon out the journey they were take their character on . Abrams sic up innumerous interrogation that Lucasfilm had no musical theme how to answer , and when answer were provided , they were so at betting odds with fan prospect that they generated an acute recoil . In truth , no form - rectification could perchance set the problems Lucasfilm had build up for themselves , because they went to the heart of the decision - making processes that spurt theStar Warssequel trilogy .
Next : Star Wars : The Rise of Skywalker ’s Ending Explained ( & What Happens Next )
