Twilight
A dream Stephenie Meyer had about a lamia twinkle in the woods turned into one of the most popular young - adult book and movie series of all time . Each book in the series obtain a movie version , with four dissimilar directors devote their take on the history . The films did a fairly corking job of get the smell of the books they ’re based on , but , like all script - to - screen adaptations , sure things were suffer along the way .
With the recent handout of the long - awaitedMidnight Sun , and all five picture show being useable to stream , it ’s time to revisit both the books and the moving picture and see how they compare .
Books: The Timeline
The firstTwilightfilm condenses the story so that the events of the first book take place over the brace of rough three months , rather than the five calendar month it admit for the same events to extend in the book . It make sense that this modification had to be made , as a film only has about two hours to tell a complete narrative . However , the book ’s long timeline takes more of a ho-hum - burn approach to Bella and Edward ’s relationship , while also give lecturer more time to witness these graphic symbol falling for one another .
Movies: The Music
One of the best lineament oftheTwilightmoviesis the soundtracks . The first movie has a soundtrack that ’s alternative , angsty , and get the vibe of the film ; theNew Moonsoundtrack feel like a natural progression and maturation , with songs reflecting the themes of the 2d film;Eclipse ’s soundtrack works to transition the serial publication from the indie flavor of the first two movies to the more mainstream , popping - feel of theBreaking Dawn ’s . Of course , books typically do n’t come with a musical component , so this may be an unjust advantage . But , theTwilightsoundtracks are truly large , and these comparisons are a byproduct of trying to liken two dissimilar mediums for storytelling .
Books: The Supporting Characters
The Cullens , the wolf pack , and Bella ’s human friends all receive deeper characterization in the Book than in the flick . Though the movies do their best to give some screen background to grapheme like Rosalie and Jasper , their role , as well as the roles of many othersupporting characters , are greatly reduce for the sake of keeping the chief secret plan move forward .
Again , this is an expected and apprehensible alteration to the origin material for the sake of metre , but Bella ’s choice to become a vampire is flesh out well in the book through her experiences with thesesecondaryTwilightcharacters .
Movies: Charlie
Charlie Swan is the unknown MVP of theTwilightsaga . All he does is get it on his girl and heed his own business . Billy Burke ’s enactment of possibly the least problematic father of all meter made the character universally do it by rooter , even as he mostly stay put out of the action . Of of course , it ’s Stephenie ’s excogitation of the character that is the base for this great performance , but Burke ( and screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg ) really elevated the character to something particular .
Books: The Supernatural
One of the master difficulties the film faced was with trying to apply maturate human actor to portray characters that were neither deathly nor human . In the books , vampires are discover as unchanging beings with supernatural beauty and strangely colored eyes . The fact that the actors who bring the vampires to life , so to address , were aging themselves could n’t be helped , but the looks seemed to vary quite drastically from plastic film to film when it get along to the choices made by the hair and makeup departments . In addition , certain effects were unmanageable to achieve , such as the speed of the lamia and the facial expression of the creepy child .
Movies: The Vampire Side Plot
The firstTwilightbookis tell completely from Bella ’s point of purview . The threat is introduced when nomadic vampire James , Laurent , and Victoria break up a very acute baseball game game and start to hunt down Bella . The movie urinate this instauration find less out of left field by introducing these vampire earlier in the movie when fans learn that a string of semi - local murders are fall out . Bella ’s daddy , constabulary headman Swan , inquire these violent death , and a skinny friend of his dice from a vampire plan of attack . This plot of ground only be in the pic , and works to add a great sense of danger for the hearing as fans see Bella begin a relationship with a vampire .
Books: The Relationships
Movies: The Visuals
pic based on books often get a lot of pom-pom for the inevitable ways in which they alter and exclude things from the source fabric . Something that does n’t often get talked about , however , is how moving-picture show can take pages of fabric from a novel and limn the thoughts and thought of the page in a brief shot or scene better than words could do . sure visuals in theTwilightmovies are capable to do this . description of the looker of the pacific northwest do n’t do the office justice , but each film make the setting of the taradiddle a visual measure for the series . Other visuals pack emotional weight unit , such as Bella andEdward Cullenseeming to share a moment as she ’s drowning . It ’s moments like these that give the films an edge .
Books: Bella
Kristen Stewart did a phenomenal problem asBella Swan . However , it ’s much more difficult to differentiate a movie in first person , whereas the books are almost solely told from Bella ’s decimal point of perspective . Because of this , study the books tells us so much more about who Bella is as a person : how she was raised , what motivates her , and how she is feeling at any given consequence . It ’s no fault of Stewart ’s that book Bella has greater depth and point in the books .
Movies: The Action
Action has never really beena focal point ofTwilight . The series , is about romance first , and the supernatural world second . There ’s only a handful of action chronological succession in the book , and most of them describe training for battle buff do n’t actually get to see . The movies have the advantage of being able to show this . Viewers see the Cullens fight James , something Bella ca n’t delineate in the books as she ’s unconscious ; They also get to see the struggle between the newborns , the Cullens , and the werewolf inEclipse . Additionally , actions sequence are tuck into the films for the interest of furnish a bit of tension and agitation to audiences . These change act well for the movie , and are an example of why the adaptation that ’s 100 % close is n’t always the best avenue .
NEXT : Twilight : 10 Ways Jacob get bad And bad
