Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore
Warning : This post curb coddler for marvelous Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledore
antic Beasts : The mystery of Dumbledoreis the third in the franchise , but when is in reality set ? The timeline revealed within the tale make a plot hole in the overall serial of events , which start in 1926 and , if the final two films in the five - pic dealership are produced , will end in 1945 with Gellert Grindelwald ’s fall from power .
InFantastic Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledore , Jacob Kowalski is roped back into helping Newt Scamander and Albus Dumbledore , to which he agrees primarily because he wants to help Queenie Goldstein after she leaves to connect Grindelwald at the final stage of the 2nd film . When Kowalski and Newt meet up again , however , the former order it ’s been one year since he met Newt in 1926 , ostensibly revealingFantastic Beasts 3is fix at some point in 1927 . Only the first two film have a time gap of a few months . The relaxation of the films in the enfranchisement are suppose to be set old age aside , especially considering the amount of time they span and therise of Grindelwald ’s powerbefore he is in conclusion defeated for good .
Related : Every Harry Potter Character Alive During Fantastic wolf ' Timeline
wild animate being : The Secrets of Dumbledoreis suppose to be define in 1932 , which mean it ’s in reality been six years since the outcome of The Crimes of Grindelwald , which rent seat at the tail end of 1932 . This discrepancy leaves a large gap in the timeline of the franchise , which is supposed to be in chronological ordering . Unlike theHarry Potterfranchise , however , theFantastic Beastsfilms are n’t meant to take place a year apart . This is a cinema serial publication that traverse nearly two decades and it makes more sense forThe Secrets of Dumbledoreto be set years after the second film . It get Kowalski’ssadness about lose Queenieall the more strong , and it explain why his bakery is empty , as though he has n’t put any exploit into keeping it up for a long while — not just a few months .
The space between Newt and Tina Goldstein , who was promote to Head Auror in the U.S. , also nominate more signified if it was year , and not months , that pass between films . The idea thatFantastic animal 3is set only a year after the event of the first film make a timeline government issue for the audience and the future of the franchise ; after all , ifFantastic Beasts 3is set in 1927 and not in 1932 , then the time jump out in the fourth instalment would be far more jarring . As an instance , Theseus nevermentions Leta Lestrangein the picture show . This is okay since the celluloid is plant in 1932 , but it does n’t function if it ’s only been a few month sinceThe criminal offence of Grindelwald , which Kowalski is propose . A six - year leap leaves space for the account to prosper over fourth dimension , giving the characters time to bring around between battles and deaths .
Kowalski mentioningFantastic Beasts 3takes place in 1927 when it ’s been revealed the film is set in 1932 could be an oversight . It ’s also potential Kowalski is only confused about how long Queenie has actually been go because he does n’t want to face the Sojourner Truth . He was regard her in his bakery when she was n’t actually there at the start ofFantastic Beasts : The Secrets of Dumbledore . Whatever the suit , the timeline not lining upto what we know about the film ’s setting is an error that could be rectified inFantastic brute 4 , though it confuse the chronology of outcome that have already aim space .
Next : rattling Beasts 3 Ending Explained & Future Setup ( In Detail )
