Related
First introduced in 1963 , Stan Lee and Jack Kirby’sX - Menhave undergo many changes over the course of nearly 50 years , both in term of roster lineup and the personality of those within . One of the openhanded character in the chronicle of the comics is undoubtedly Rogue , but she did n’t get her first appearance until the former 1980s .
Since her introduction , Rogue has gone on to prove herself as one of the most emotionally compelling X - man in the enfranchisement ’s account , even function so far as to incur a successful , long - running cinema adaptation portrayed byTrue rip ’s Anna Paquin . Even still , not every Redditor is enamour .
Rogue In The Comics Is Boring
Redditorcalgilclaimed to be a " hugeX - Menfan , " but their hint that " for a retentive time " Rogue " just flew around " and had " No veridical specific power " were encounter with controversy .
For instance , there waschronorogue01 , who quoted the Redditor ’s command on exponent and replied " Um , that is her index engrossment . Which she definitely used consistently and is a immense part of her origin and joining the X - mankind . " The latter Redditor has a good percentage point ; even putting the comics apart , Rogue ’s power absorption was one of the originalX - Menfilm ’s core secret plan points .
Rogue And Gambit Weren’t A Good Match
One Redditor , calliduslupus , was compendious when generate their thoughts on the sexual union of Rogue and Cajun cardshark Gambit , who is also acontroversial fictional character on Reddit : " Rogue and Gambit are a terrible couple . " Most fans of the franchise , and of the two character , would disagree , like360Saturn , who write that " Gambit and Rogue are the best ten - Men duo . "
Mazzidazsagreed with 360Saturn , station " Gambit and Rogue are INFINITELY more entertaining than 99 % of other span . " The pair do make for a good match , which includes their brief us - against - the - world plotline in theUltimate X - Menseries .
The Movies' Take On Rogue Is Better Than The Comic’s Earliest Version
Paquin ’s execution as Rogue have never been a point of controversy or criticism for thediversely - receivedX - Menfilms , but they ’re not fancy by fan as the end all be all of Rogue characterizations . However , TraptNSuitbelieves that " Movie / Anna Paquin Rogue is a better eccentric than the first decennary of comics Rogue . "
Both version are worthy of their fans , but the Redditor does n’t elaborate on why they experience the cinematic rendition take on the bar . Regardless , most would disagree with the judgement .
Movie Rogue Is Not Fleshed Out At All
Redditorriot21xwrote that they did n’t handle for the films ' take on Rogue whatsoever , claim she never felt " flesh out at all " and that she came across as " whiny , unconfident … Just awful …. " Whether it was the tone or message , the Redditor ’s comment has a vote score of -2 .
Furthermore , DarkAlphaZerobrought up a good breaker point : " Well , Roguewasnoticeably new than the sleep of the go - man when she joined in the strip , not to the point of being from a unlike generation like Kitty but still younger than the rest except for maybe Nightcrawler . "
Rogue’s Death Touch Is Getting Old
1204Spartawrote that they are " world-weary of Rogue going back and forward " when it get along to her unfortunate mutant ability to extract the free energy from any living animal she touches .
If anything about Rogue is compelling , it ’s her inner struggle with intimacy . Everyone she lie with , she ca n’t touch . If she does and does so long enough , she fall back them evermore . This personal struggle makes Rogue one of the most empathy - desirable X - Men , and taking that away from her is what would show truly boring .
X-Treme Rogue Looks Better Than 90s Rogue
In a inclination of opinionslongangrey123felt might qualify as unpopular , the Redditor drop a line , " X - Treme Rogue bet good than 90s Rogue …. "
Besides perhaps the original streak of comics , Rogue ’s most famous embodiment would undoubtedly be from the beloved cartoon serial publication from the 1990s . Along with a jolly iconic appearance , the eccentric was dilate beyond the deadly ramifications of her powers . While that home battle help make Rogue interesting , it ’s fundamentally the same battle fought by anotherfan - favorite X - Man : Jean Grey .
The Movies Nailed The Core Of The Character
Spiderlanderwrites that they enjoyedX - MenandX2 : 10 - Men Uniteddirector Bryan Singer ’s take on the character which they acknowledge was n’t a " 1:1 translation " but feel " cop the core of the fibre . " Many Redditors disagree with the character ’s core being befittingly translate , even if most also give the film version a compliment or two .
However , chronorogue01posited that " X - film Rogue is the definition of boring " and she ’s " unrecognisable as the theatrical role . It did the character no justice . No sass , a weakling , no villain chronicle or redemption arc …. " A picture has limited screen clock time for each graphic symbol , so not every one of them will be fleshed out fully . However , all of the latter Redditor ’s points are precise , as is their acknowledgment that the flick throw overboard the interesting and layered dynamic she has with Mystique and , particularly , Gambit .
Her Accent Should Have Stayed After The First Movie
CaptainNinjaXbrought up something that ’s often pick apart about 2000’sX - gentleman’s gentleman : some of the persona ' accents . In their words , " Where did her Southern accent go after the first movie ? Same thing with Storm . Accent and then no accent . "
The Redditor ’s view is unpopular because most viewing audience could scarcely say they missed the magnified stress , particularly the flimsy Kenyan accent used by Berry . moreover , it ’s debatable that Paquin ’s Rogue lost her accent entirely , which was the vitrine for Storm .
NEXT:10 Things Only Comic Book Fans get it on About X - Men ’s Magneto
20th Century Studios
20th Century Studios
